Link

Social

Embed

Disable autoplay on embedded content?

Download

Download
Download Transcript


[00:00:09]

HE'S SLEEPING.

HE'S SLEEPING.

SOMEONE WAKE HIM UP.

COMMISSIONER ACOSTA

[Call to Order]

.

I CAN SEE HIM ONLINE, BUT HE CANNOT SEE US OR HEAR US.

CHAIR.

I'M REACHING OUT TO MR. ACOSTA.

OKAY.

UM, KEEP GOING.

KEEP ON GOING.

COMMISSIONER BOONE.

DO NOT SEE COMMISSIONER BOONE.

UM, OUR NEWEST PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER, UH, AS OF JUST THIS WEEK.

COMMISSIONER ALEJANDRO FLORES HERE.

CONGRATS.

THANK YOU.

CONGRATULATIONS.

COMMISSIONER FLOYD RIGHT HERE.

COMMISSIONER FOUTS.

CAN THEY NOT HEAR ONLINE? CAN YOU GUYS HEAR US? OH, OKAY.

UM, COMMISSIONER FOUTS IS HERE.

CAN Y'ALL HEAR ME BY ANY CHANCE? YES, I CAN HEAR YOU.

OKAY, SO COMMISSIONER ACOSTA, I I CAN HEAR YOU COMMISSIONER FAST.

I CANNOT HEAR THE COMMISSIONER'S NEITHER.

CAN I, UM, TURN ON YOU? OKAY.

WE, WE CAN HEAR YOU GUYS, BUT THAT DOESN'T DO YOU ANY GOOD? UH, HER UH, COMMISSIONER GREENBERG.

WE CAN READ THE SUBTITLES.

SO YEAH, I'M TRYING TO DO THAT.

IT'S A LITTLE, UH, COMMISSIONER JOHNSON.

DO NOT SEE COMMISSIONER JOHNSON.

CHAIR SMITH.

I'M PRESENT.

COMMISSIONER STERN HERE.

AND COMMISSIONER THOMPSON IS OUT OF TOWN.

SO WE HAVE SEVEN COMMISSIONERS PRESENT WORKING ON THE AUDIO FOR TWO.

DO WE NEED TO WAIT UNTIL WE GET AUDIO ON THE OTHER TWO? 'CAUSE WE ONLY HAVE ONE.

THEY SAID THEY COULD READ THE, SOMETIMES WE ONLY HAVE FIVE HERE.

CHAIR IF WE CAN JUST REMAIN AT HE SWEAR A COUPLE.

WAIT, THEY'RE GIVING US A THUMBS UP.

SO Y'ALL, CAN Y'ALL HEAR US NOW? CAN Y'ALL HEAR US NOW? THEY GAVE ME A THUMBS UP.

NOPE.

, .

THEY WERE THERE FOR A MINUTE.

WHATEVER YOU DID, COME BACK AND DO IT AGAIN.

.

DO WE HAVE TO RECESS? SHERIFF, WE COULD RECESS FOR SIX MINUTES.

SIX MINUTES? OKAY.

WE'LL TAKE A SIX MINUTE RECESS TILL WE CAN GET THE AUDIO WORKED OUT.

BACK TO ORDER.

IT IS 6 0 8.

SORRY FOR THE AUDIO PROBLEMS. UM, JUST TO MAKE SURE, COMMISSIONER COSTA, YOU'RE LINE, IS THAT OKAY? AND COMMISSIONER F YOU? OKAY.

SO WE HAVE SEVEN SEVEN COMMISSIONERS, UH, HERE TODAY.

DO WE HAVE ANY PUBLIC SPEAKERS? OKAY, HAVING NO ONE SIGNED UP FOR PUBLIC SPEAKING, WE WILL GO TO APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES.

DO WE HAVE ANY COMMENTS ON THE MINUTES? AND I'LL READ THE REST OF THE CONSENT AGENDA.

ANY COMMENTS ON THE MINUTES? HEARING NONE.

ITEM ONE

[Consent Agenda]

FOR THE CONSENT AGENDA WILL BE THE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FROM JULY 18TH, 2023.

ITEM TWO IS A REZONING CASE, C 14 20 23 DASH 0 0 7 3.

DESAL GARDENS AT 13 2 0 8 AND 13 300 AND A HALF DESAL ROAD.

IT IS REZONING CASE FROM SF SIX CO FOR TRACK ONE AND L L C O FOR TRACK TWO TO MF FOUR.

IT IS RECOMMENDED AND ON THE CONSENT AGENDA, ITEM THREE IS THE C 14 20 23 0 0 6 7 STUDENT UNION EDITION AND NEW GYMNASIUM FOR HYDE PARK SCHOOLS.

IT IS A REZONING CASE FROM SSF TWO TO GEO IS LOCATED 11 400 NORTH MOPAC EXPRESSWAY SERVICE ROAD.

IT IS RECOMMENDED BY STAFF.

AND ON THE CONSENT AGENDA, ITEM FOUR C 14 20 22 DASH OH 1 76 0 6 ALBERT ROAD IS A REZONING FROM DR TO SSF SIX.

IT IS A STAFF POSTPONEMENT TO SEPTEMBER 5TH.

IS THAT CORRECT? OKAY.

ITEM NUMBER FIVE, ENVIRONMENTAL VARIANCES.

SP 2022 DASH 1 6 70 17 0 3 NORTH RIVER HILLS ROAD.

MARINO RECONSTRUCTION IS AT 1703 RIVER HILLS ROAD.

THERE ARE TWO VARIANCES, HOWEVER, ITEM VARIANCE NUMBER ONE, THE REQUEST TO VARY THE L D C 25 8 2 61 CRITIC WATER QUALITY ZONE DEVELOPMENT TO ALLOW IN THE CRITIC WATER QUALITY ZONE OF LAKE AUSTIN DEVELOPMENT OF A GASOLINE FUEL LINE WITH A DISPENSARY AT THE DOCK FOR REFUELING PRIVATE BOATS HAS BEEN REMOVED AND WITHDRAWN.

SO THAT IS NOT A PORTION OF OUR PRESENTATION OR DISCUSSION TONIGHT.

HOWEVER, VARIANCE NUMBER TWO IS A REQUEST TO VARY FROM L D C 25 8 DASH 360 8 E TO ALLOW MORE THAN 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE IN LAKE AUSTIN.

IT WAS RECOMMENDED BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL COMMISSION WITH CONDITIONS.

AND THAT IS GONNA BE WHAT WE'RE GONNA BE DISCUSSING FOR PART FIVE IS JUST THE SECOND PART OF THAT ITEM.

UH, ITEM SIX, SITE PLAN EXTENSION SP 2017 DASH OH 2 4 8

[00:05:01]

C XT TWO DEERFIELD LOT ONE C IN DISTRICT 8 36 0 1 DAVIS LANE.

IT IS A CONSENT, UH, AGENDA ITEM AND IS RECOMMENDED BY STAFF ITEM SEVEN S SP 20 17 0 1 4 3 C XT MARQUEE RANCH SELF STORAGE AT 97 18 ANDERSON MILL ROAD.

IT IS ANOTHER, UM, EXTENSION, ONE YEAR EXTENSION.

IT IS POSTPONED BY STAFF.

THAT'S AN APPEAL AS AN, AS AN APPEAL, I'M SORRY, AN APPEAL TO AN ADMINISTRATIVE ONE YEAR EXTENSION GRANT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED SITE PLAN.

IT IS A STAFF POSTPONEMENT TO, YEAH.

IS THERE A DATE? SEPTEMBER 2ND OR TWO WEEKS CHAIR COMMISSIONER LEES ON ANDOVER.

THAT'S A TWO WEEK POSTPONEMENT.

OKAY, SO THAT'S TWO WEEK POSTPONEMENT TO 15TH SEPTEMBER OR WHAT IS THIS? AUGUST 15TH.

OKAY, FINALLY, ITEM EIGHT, FINAL PLAT C 8 20 22 DASH OH 2 21 1, A RIVER PARK SOUTH 4,700 EAST RIVERSIDE DRIVE COUNTRY CLUB WEST CREEK.

IT IS A FINAL PLATTS APPROVAL OF A FINAL PLATT OUT OF A PRELIM.

UH, AND IT IS A APPROVAL WITH CONDITIONS PER EXHIBIT C AND IS ON THE CONSENT AGENDA.

SO AGAIN, THE CONSENT AGENDA IS THE MINUTES ITEM ONE, THE REZONING FOR ITEM TWO, REZONING FOR ITEM THREE, STAFF POSTPONEMENT FOR ITEM FOUR TO SEPTEMBER 5TH.

ITEM FIVE IS DISCUSSION.

SO THAT'S NOT A CONSENT AGENDA.

IT'S ITEM SIX IS A CONSENT AGENDA ITEM FOR A THREE YEAR EXTENSION TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED SITE PLAN.

ITEM SEVEN IS A POSTPONEMENT TO FOR TWO WEEKS TO EIGHT 15 AND ITEM EIGHT IS A FINAL APPROVAL.

APPROVAL WITH CONDITIONS AS RECOMMENDED EXHIBIT C.

THAT'S THE CONSENT AGENDA.

DO I HEAR A MOTION TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA? COMMISSIONER FLORES REC RECOMMENDS CLOSING THE PUBLIC HEARING AND APPROVING AND COMMISSIONER GREENBERG HAS SECONDED THAT.

ANY DISCUSSION? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE.

AYE.

ALL THOSE OPPOSED, SAME SIGN.

THAT IS UNANIMOUS APPROVAL.

SO WE'LL GO

[5. Environmental Variances: SP-2022-0167D - 1703 N. River Hills Road Marina Reconstruction; District 10]

FROM THERE TO ITEM FIVE.

AND AGAIN, THIS IS, I'LL READ IT ONE MORE TIME.

SP 2022 DASH OH 1 67 D 1703 NORTH HILLS ROAD MARINA RECONSTRUCTION.

AND WE'RE ONLY HEARING ITEM THE SECOND PORTION OF THIS, WHICH IS A REQUEST TO VARY FROM THE L D C 25 8 360 8 E TO ALLOW MORE THAN 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGING IN LAKE AUSTIN.

THAT'S THE ONLY ITEM WE'RE TAKING UP IS THAT ENVIRONMENTAL VARIANCE APPROVAL.

IS THERE A, IS THERE A STAFF PRESENTATION OR STRAIGHT TO THE APPLICANT? OKAY.

WHENEVER YOU'RE READY.

WHERE IS IT GONNA BE SHOWING IT WAS, IT WAS, IT'S OUTSIDE.

OKAY, OUTSIDE.

NOW WE GOT IT.

ALL RIGHT.

GREAT.

CAN Y'ALL HEAR ME OKAY? PERFECT.

UH, GOOD EVENING COMMISSIONERS.

MY NAME IS MIRANDA REINHARD.

I AM AN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENTIST SENIOR IN THE WATERSHED PROTECTION DEPARTMENT AND I AM THE WETLAND BIOLOGIST REVIEWER FOR THIS CASE.

UH, THE CASE IS 1703 NORTH RIVER HILLS ROAD MARINA CONSTRUCTION, LOCATED AT 1703 RIVER HILLS ROAD.

7 8 7 3 3.

NEXT SLIDE.

THE SITE IS LOCATED IN WEST AUSTIN.

NEXT SLIDE.

[00:10:02]

AND IT'S LOCATED ALONG LAKE AUSTIN, UM, ALONG ACROSS FROM 360, UH, WHERE THAT YELLOW STAR IS THERE ON THE SLIDE.

NEXT SLIDE.

THE SITE IS LOCATED IN THE LAKE AUSTIN WATERSHED CLASSIFIED WATER, SU SUPPLY RURAL.

IT'S LOCATED WITHIN THE DRINKING WATER PROTECTION ZONE, FULL AND LIMITED PURPOSE JURISDICTIONS AS WELL AS COUNCIL DISTRICT 10.

THERE ARE NO CREEKS OR CREEK BUFFERS ON THE SITE.

HOWEVER, THERE ARE TWO WETLAND CRITICAL ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES OR CEFS AND A LAKE AUSTIN BUFFER ON THE SITE.

NEXT SLIDE.

THE VARIANCE REQUEST FOR THIS CASE IS TO REQUEST TO VARY FROM L D C 25 8 360 8 E TO ALLOW MORE THAN 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE IN LAKE AUSTIN.

NEXT SLIDE.

UH, THE PROJECT IS PROPOSING TO MODIFY AN EXISTING MARINA BUILT PRIOR TO 1965.

THE EXISTING 21 SLIP MARINA IS SHOWN, HIGHLIGHTED IN BLUE ON THIS SLIDE AND IN THE PROPOSED 16 SLIP MARINA IS SHOWN IN YELLOW ON THIS SLIDE.

THE CLIPPED PLAN SET IMAGE IN THE CENTER SHOWCASES THE OVERLAY OF BOTH THE EXISTING AND PROPOSED MARINA OVERLAP AND THE EXISTING FOOTPRINT IS OUTLINED IN LAVENDER.

THE PROJECT PROPOSES TO PROPOSES TO REPLACE A MALFUNCTIONING EXISTING 21 SLIP MARINA WITH A 16 SLIP CODE COMPLIANT, UH, SITE WITHIN THE EXISTING FOOTPRINT CODE ALLOWS FOR CONSTRUCTION OF A MARINA AND ALLOWS FOR MODIFICATION AND MAINTENANCE OF NON COMPLYING DOCKS.

L D C 25 8 360 8 E ALLOWS UP TO 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGING IN THE LAKE FOR A SINGLE SITE PLAN PERMIT APPLICATION.

AND EACH SITE PLAN TYPICALLY CONTAINS ONE TO TWO SLIPS.

UM, THE PROJECT IS PROPOSING 6.1 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE PER BOAT SLIP FOR A TOTAL OF 97.4 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE.

IF THIS PROJECT CAME IN AS 16 SEPARATE SITE PLANS FOR 16 SEPARATE BOAT SLIPS AND PROPOSED 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE PER BOAT SLIP, THEN THAT WOULD BE A TOTAL OF 400 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGE AND THE QUANTITY OF DREDGE PER BOAT SLIP AND OVERALL TOTAL IS MUCH LESS THAN ALLOWED PER CODE IF THIS WAS FILED AS 16 SEPARATE BOAT SLIPS, OR SORRY, 16 SEPARATE SITE PLANS.

UH, THE VARIANCE IS REQUIRED TO ALLOW A QUANTITY OF DREDGING THAT IS DICTATED BY THE NUMBER OF BOAT SLIPS AND IS LESS PER BOAT SLIP, APPROXIMATELY 6.1 CUBIC YARDS AND THE QUANTITY OF DREDGING ALLOWED BY CODE FOR A SINGLE BOAT SLIP 25 CUBIC YARDS.

NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

SIMILAR VARIANCES HAVE BEEN GRANTED FOR PROJECTS WITH SIMILAR CODE REQUIREMENTS.

AN EXAMPLE OF A SIMILAR PROPERTY IS WEST HARBOR MARINA SITE PLAN NUMBER SP 20 18 0 2 2 1 C.

THIS PROJECT PROPOSES TO REPLACE AN EXISTING 20 PROPOSED TO REPLACE AN EXISTING 28 SLIP MARINA WITH 26 CODE COMPLIANCE SLIPS WITHIN THE EXISTING FOOTPRINT.

AND THIS PROJECT WAS GRANTED A VARIANCE IN 2019 TO DREDGE APPROXIMATELY 16 CUBIC YARDS PER BOAT SLIP FOR A TOTAL OF 422 CUBIC YARDS.

THIS, UH, VARIANCE FOR 1703 NORTH RIVER HILLS ROAD MARINA RECONSTRUCTIONS VARIS APPLICATION PROPOSES TO DREDGE ONLY 6.1 CUBIC YARDS PER SLIP FOR A TOTAL OF 97.4 CUBIC YARDS.

SO AS YOU CAN SEE, THE AMOUNT OF DREDGE PROPOSED FOR THE SIMILAR VARIANCE IS MUCH LESS PER SLIP AND IN TOTAL.

NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

IN ADDITION TO THE REQUIRED WETLAND MITIGATION AND BULKHEAD MITIGATION PLANTINGS, THE APPLICANT IS INSTALLING A SEDIMENT BOOM OR TURBIDITY CURTAIN TO MINIMIZE SEDIMENT DISTURBANCE THAT IS OUTLINED IN PURPLE.

ON THIS SLIDE, THE APPLICANT IS ALSO INSTALLING TEMPORARY ORANGE CONSTRUCTION FENCING AROUND THE ENTIRE BOUNDARIES OF THE WETLAND CRITICAL ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURE OR C E F, NOT INCLUDED IN THE LIMITS OF CONSTRUCTION OR L O C TO PREVENT ENCROACHMENT INTO THE WETLAND.

C E F, THE WETLAND.

THE WETLAND IS OUTLINED IN GREEN AND THE TEMPORARY ORANGE CONSTRUCTION FENCING IS OUTLINED IN ORANGE.

THE APPLICANT IS ALSO PROVIDING ADDITIONAL WETLAND MITIGATION PLANTINGS IN THE WATER ALONG THE SHORELINE AS OUTLINED IN BLUE.

NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

IN ADDITION TO THE REQUIRED 301 WETLAND PLANT WETLAND MITIGATION AND BULKHEAD MITIGATION PLANTINGS, THE APPLICANT IS PROVIDING 32 ADDITIONAL WETLAND MITIGATION PLANTINGS OF AMERICAN WATER, WILLOW, OR JUSTICE SIA AMERICANA.

GIANT CUT GRASS IS THE SYNOPSIS.

LACER OR OTHER HERBIVORE RESISTANT AATE WETLAND SPECIES EMERGED IN THE WATER ALONG THE SHORELINE.

THE WETLAND IS AGAIN OUTLINED IN GREEN HERE, THE REQUIRED WETLAND AND BULKHEAD MITIGATION PLANTINGS ARE OUTLINED IN DARK BLUE AND THEN THE ADDITIONAL WETLAND MITIGATION PLANTINGS ARE OUTLINED IN LIGHT BLUE.

NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

SIMILAR VARIANCES HAVE BEEN GRANTED FOR PROJECTS WITH SIMILAR CODE REQUIREMENTS AND SIMILAR CIRCUMSTANCES TO ALLOW REHABILITATION AND OR REPLACEMENT OF AN EXISTING MARINA.

THE VARIANCE IS NECESSITATED BY

[00:15:01]

TOPOGRAPHIC FEATURES NOT DESIGNED CHOICE.

THE AMOUNT OF DREDGE REQUESTED IS THE MINIMUM AMOUNT NEEDED TO MAINTAIN AN EXISTING MARINA AND ALLOW NAVIGABLE CLEARANCE FOR THE BOAT.

THE VARIANCE IS ALSO THE MINIMUM DEVIATION FROM CODE.

THE CODE ALLOWS UP TO 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGING ASSOCIATED WITH CONSTRUCTION OF A SINGLE BOAT SLIP AND THE THE PROPOSED DREDGE NECESSARY TO BUILD A NAVIGABLE 16 BOAT SLIP DOCK, UH, 16 SLIP BOAT DOCK WITHIN THE EXISTING BOAT DOCK IS FAR LOWER, 6.1 CUBIC YARDS PER SLIP THAN THE DREDGE ALLOWED 25 CUBIC YARDS PER SLIP.

IF THE BOAT DOCK WAS PERMITTED ON A SLIP BY SLIP BASIS, THE VARIANCE IS UNLIKELY TO RESULT IN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES, UH, AND HARMFUL ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES.

THE SEDIMENT BOOM WOULD BE INSTALLED PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTAINED FOR THE DURATION OF THE PROJECT TO MINIMIZE DISCHARGES TO THE LAKE.

DENYING DREDGE TO A NAVIGABLE DEPTH POTENTIALLY HARMS THE WATER QUALITY OF THE LAKE DUE TO TURNING OF THE LAKE BED.

BY BOATS LEAVING SEDIMENT LADEN WATER IN THEIR LAKE WATER QUALITY WOULD BE EQUAL TO OR BETTER THAN THE WATER QUALITY WITHOUT THE VARIANCE.

DREDGING IS NECESSARY TO ELIMINATE THE TURNING OF THE LAKE BED BY BOAT TRAFFIC LEADING TO SEDIMENT LAY LADEN LAKE WATER.

THERE WILL BE A REPLACEMENT OF THE BULKHEAD THAT IS CURRENTLY ALLOWING SEDIMENT TO ENTER LAKE AUSTIN WETLAND MITIGATION, BULKHEAD MITIGATION TREE PROTECTION AND THE INSTALLATION OF TEMPORARY ORANGE CONSTRUCTION.

FENCING AROUND THE WETLAND C E F WILL POSITIVELY IMPACT WATER QUALITY AND ADDITIONAL WETLAND PLANTINGS AND PROTECTING THE WETLAND C E F WILL ALSO POSITIVELY IMPACT WATER QUALITY.

NEXT SLIDE.

STAFF RECOMMENDS THIS VARIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS.

ONE, INSTALL THE SEDIMENT BOOM TO MINIMIZE SEDIMENT DISTURBANCE.

TWO.

INSTALL TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION TEMPORARY ORANGE CONSTRUCTION FENCING AROUND THE WETLAND C E F, UM, NOT INCLUDING THE L O C TO PREVENT ENCROACHMENT WITHIN THE WETLAND.

C E F THREE PROVIDE ADDITIONAL WETLAND MITIGATION BEYOND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE WETLANDS.

THAT INCLUDES THE 32 PLANTINGS THAT WERE WAR RESISTANT OBLIGATE WETLAND SPECIES EMERGED IN THE WATER ALONG THE SHORELINE AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL COMMISSION DID VOTE IN AGREEMENT WITH STAFF ON NOVEMBER 16TH, 2022.

UH, NEXT SLIDE.

AND THANK YOU THAT INCLUDES CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.

SO IF Y'ALL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER THEM AFTER THE APPLICANT'S PRESENTATION.

THANK YOU CHAIR.

WE'LL NOW HEAR FROM THE APPLICANT MS. SMITH.

MS. SMITH, YOU'LL HAVE SIX MINUTES.

OKAY.

ISN'T THAT GOOD? OKAY.

GOOD EVENING, CHAIR AND COMMISSIONERS.

I'M JANICE SMITH, THE ENGINEER OF RECORD FOR 1703 NORTH RIVER HILLS ROAD, MARINA RECON RECONSTRUCTION, A K A, THE PIER ELLE MEAD DESH BLACKWELL'S.

THE OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE AND THE CO-APPLICANT ON THIS VARIANCE APPLICATION WE'RE APPLYING FOR A VARIANCE TO DREDGE MORE THAN 25 CUBIC YARDS FOR A GRANDFATHERED 16 SLIT MARINA.

WE CAME HERE TONIGHT WITH RECOMMENDATIONS FOR APPROVAL FROM BOTH THE CITY OF AUSTIN REVIEW STAFF AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL COMMISSION.

NEXT SLIDE.

I'M SORRY.

DID I NOT TELL YOU TO? IT'S ALRIGHT.

OKAY.

THE PIER WAS CONSTRUCTED PRIOR TO 1965 AND WAS OPEN IN ONE FORM OR ANOTHER FROM THE 1920S TO 2005.

THE PROJECT SITE CONTAINS AN ABANDONED RESTAURANT PAVED DANCE FLOOR STAGE PARKING LOT BULKHEAD EXISTING 18 SLIP MARINA, THE NORTH DOCK, AND A SEPARATE THREE SLIP MARINA THAT PREVIOUSLY HAD A GAS PUMP, THE SOUTH DOCK.

NEXT SLIDE.

THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS FOR THE REST OF THE SITE HASN'T YET BEGUN, BUT THE CONDITION OF BOTH BOAT DOCKS IS TOO DANGEROUS TO LEAVE UNADDRESSED.

THE DOCKS WERE RED TAGGED IN OCTOBER, 2019, AND A SITE PLAN IS REQUIRED TO RECONSTRUCT THE DOCKS.

THE PROPOSED PROJECT WILL RECONSTRUCT THE DOCKS AND THE BULKHEAD.

NEXT SLIDE.

BY TODAY'S PERMITTING REGULATIONS, THE OLD STRUCTURES WERE A 21 SLIP MARINA.

THE PROPOSED PROJECT WILL HAVE 16 SLIPS BE CODE COMPLIANT WITHIN THE EXISTING FOOTPRINTS AND FIX A FAILING BULKHEAD.

NEXT SLIDE.

THE CURRENT WATER DEPTH IS TOO SHALLOW TO ACCOMMODATE MODERN BOATS AND BOAT LIFTS.

CODE PROVIDES FOR DREDGE UP TO 25 CUBIC YARDS TO BE APPROVED ADMINISTRATIVELY, HOWEVER, CODE DOESN'T DISTINGUISH BETWEEN WHETHER ONE SLIP OR 16 SLIPS IN THIS CASE ARE BEING PERMITTED.

THE PROPOSED DREDGE PER SLIP FOR THIS VARIANCE APPLICATION IS ONLY SIX CUBIC YARDS PER SLIP.

OR 25% OF THE DREDGE ALLOW FOR THE SLIP IN A ONE SLIP BOAT DOCK WHILE THE DOCK CAN BE RECONSTRUCTED WITHOUT THE VARIANCE, THE OWNER'S PROJECT TEAM AND CITY STAFF AGREE THAT IT WOULD BE BETTER TO REMOVE ACCUMULATED SILT AND INCREASE THE WATER DEPTH WITH EROSION CONTROLS IN PLACE WITHOUT THE VARIANCE.

THE SILT WILL LIKELY BE CHURNED UP BY BOAT PROPELLERS AND LIFTS REPEATEDLY WITH NO EROSION CONTROLS AT WORK.

A SIMILAR PROJECT, A GRANDFATHER 26 SLIP MARINA NAMED WEST HARBOR MARINA

[00:20:01]

WAS GRANTED A DREDGE VARIANCE IN 2019 FOR 16.2 CUBIC YARDS PER SLIP.

THE CORE OF ENGINEERS ALSO REGULATES DREDGE OVER 25 CUBIC YARDS ON LAKE AUSTIN.

THE CORE IS AN ADDITIONAL LAYER OF REVIEW, WHICH WE'VE COMPLETED.

WE RECEIVED NOTICE THAT THE SCOPE OF THE DREDGE IN THIS SITE PLAN IS APPROVED UNDER THE REGIONAL GENERAL PERMIT GOVERNING BOAT, RAMPS AND MINOR FACILITIES.

IN SHORT, WE'RE GOOD TO GO WITH THE P WITH THE CORE.

THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME TONIGHT, ELLE AND I ASK YOU TO APPROVE THIS VARIANCE APPLICATION FOR DREDGE OVER 25 CUBIC YARDS.

AND WE'RE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE.

THANK YOU.

NOW HERE, UH, FROM THE OPPOSITION, MR. HERRON, I WAS HERE TO SPEAK ONLY BRIDE AND ONE HAVE TWO.

SO I WOOHOO A MOTION.

I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO CLOSE A PUBLIC HEARING.

OKAY.

I HERE A SECOND.

I'LL SECOND IT.

OKAY.

MOTION.

AND SECOND.

ALL THOSE IN FAVOR? SAY ON UH, UNANIMOUS.

DO WE HAVE ANY DISCUSSION? SO MICROPHONE PLEASE.

SORRY.

LET ME BE VERY CAREFUL WHAT WE'RE DOING.

UM, ASKING FOR A MOTION TO APPROVE JUST THE REQUEST OF VARIANCE L D C 25 8 360 8 TO ALLOW MORE THAN 25 CUBIC YARDS OF DREDGING IN LAKE AUSTIN.

TAKING NO ACTION ON ITEM ONE AT ALL.

SO IT'S JUST THE DREDGING THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT AND WE'RE MAKING RECOMMENDATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, UH, RE RE ADDITIONS THAT WERE ADDED AND STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS AS WELL.

SO DO I HEAR A MOTION? SO MOVED.

COMMISSIONER STERN.

DO I HEAR A SECOND? I SECOND THAT.

COMMISSIONER.

EXCUSE ME.

ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE.

JUST A QUESTION.

OKAY.

SORRY.

WOULD WE BE BETTER OFF ALSO DISAPPROVING THE FIRST ONE JUST, OR DOESN'T, IT'S BEEN WITHDRAWN, NOT NECESSARY.

CHAIR COMMISSIONER LEE AND ANDREW RIVERA, THAT IS NOT WITHIN THE PURVIEW OF THE COMMISSION AT THIS TIME.

YEAH, GOT IT.

SINCE IT WAS WITHDRAWN.

ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE.

AYE.

ALL THOSE OPPOSED PASSES UNANIMOUSLY.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

THANK YOU.

OKAY.

UM, ADAMS FROM THE COMMISSION? ANYTHING FROM THE COMMISSION? FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS? ANY, ANY FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS? COMMITTEE REPORTS, CODES AND ORDINANCES.

YOUR TURN

[COMMITTEE REPORTS]

THIS TIME.

RIGHT.

WE HAD A MEETING ON JULY 19TH.

UM, WE DISCUSSED BARN AND SPRINGS, BATH HOUSE AMENDMENT, UM, TENANT NOTIFICATION AND RELOCATION.

ELIMINATE N P A FILING DEADLINES, UNO SIGN CORRECTION.

AND WE WENT OVER THE ANNUAL INTERNAL REVIEW AND REPORT, APPROVE THE CREATION OF WORKING GROUP TO REVIEW AND PROPOSE MEETING PROCEDURES AND, UH, OKAY.

CONFERENCE PLAN, JOINT COMMITTEE.

WE HAVE A MEETING COMING UP ON THE 24TH.

UH, SO THAT'LL BE AN IMPORTANT MEETING.

SO COMMISSIONER SPUS AND THOMPSON AND THEY WILL NEED TO BE AT THAT MEETING AS WELL AS MYSELF.

UM, NOTHING ELSE HAS HAPPENED ON THAT ONE.

SMALL AREA PLANNING JOINT COMMITTEE.

UH, WE HAVE A MEETING COMING UP THAT'S ACTUALLY BEEN RESCHEDULED FOR SEPTEMBER.

OKAY.

SO NOTHING TO REPORT.

ALL RIGHT.

NOTHING TO ADJOURN.

UH, CHAIR, I HAD A QUESTION, UM, FROM THE PREVIOUS COMMITTEE.

I WAS JUST WONDERING ABOUT THE UNO SIGN ORDINANCE.

IS THAT A, UM, A SINGLE, IS THAT ABOUT A SINGLE SIGN OR WAS THERE A PERMANENT, UM, POLICY RECOMMENDED? IT WAS, IT WAS TO REMOVE THE RESTRICTION ON LIGHTED SIGNS ABOVE THE SECOND FLOOR.

THERE'D BEEN VARIANCE AFTER VARIANCE GRANTED.

UM, I DON'T KNOW WHY THIS DIDN'T GET CORRECTED WITH THE OTHER UNO CORRECTIONS, BUT SO NOW IS THIS ONE AND DONE? AND WE'LL STOP HAVING TO HEAR ABOUT EACH.

NO, IT STILL HAS TO GO TO PLANNING COMMISSION AND CITY COUNCIL.

YEAH, YEAH, YEAH.

BUT I MEAN, THE IDEA IS TO HAVE TO NOT HAVE SETTLE THIS NOW RATHER THAN ONE AT A TIME.

MM-HMM.

.

OKAY.

GREAT.

THANKS.

ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? ALRIGHT, WE'RE ADJOURNED AT 6 30, 30 MINUTES.

THAT WAS

[00:25:03]

HOPE YOU GOT YOUR THINGS TOGETHER, YOU AND.