[CALL TO ORDER]
[00:00:03]
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING.
UM, THERE THE COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS.
ALL RIGHT, WE'LL GET YOU SET UP WHEREVER YOU'D LIKE.
SO NOW HAVING A QUORUM WITHIN 30 MINUTES OF POSTED MEETING TIME, WE WILL CALL THIS MEETING TO ORDER SPECIAL CALLED MEETING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION TO ORDER AT 5:03 PM SO I'M GOING TO FIRST START OFF WITH ROLL CALL.
UM, I'LL GO BY I HOW I SEE YOU ON THE SCREEN.
DID I HEAR OR HEAR FROM COMMISSIONER SKIDMORE? OH, CAN YOU HEAR ME? OH, IT'S REALLY LOW, BUT I HEARD YOU.
UM, COMMISSIONER MAXWELL HERE.
COMMISSIONER HANEY HERE AND CHAIR HEMPEL IS HERE.
UM, TONIGHT, I KNOW WE'RE MISSING COMMISSIONER OR VICE CHAIR AZAR, UM, COMMISSIONER HOWARD AND COMMISSIONER COX.
UM, COMMISSIONER BO RAMIREZ WILL BE JOINING US IN A FEW MINUTES, AND I AM UNDERSTAND COMMISSIONER JOHNSON WILL ALSO BE JOINING US THIS EVENING, BUT HE IS NOT PRESENT YET.
ALRIGHT, SO, UM, WE'RE GONNA START OFF WITH PUBLIC COMMUNICATION THIS EVENING.
MS. GARCIA, ARE YOU MCING THIS FOR US? YES.
AND, UH, WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER SIGNED UP FOR PUBLIC COMMUNICATION, COLETTE HANKY.
COLETTE, YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES.
SEEING SHE'S NOT HERE PRESENT.
UH, THAT CONCLUDES THE SPEAKERS ON PUBLIC COMMUNICATION.
UM, AND SHE WASN'T ONLINE, CORRECT? NO CHAIR.
UM, ALRIGHT, TONIGHT'S MEETING'S HYBRID AS USUAL.
UM, SO WE'VE GOT, UM, THREE MEMBERS HERE VIRTUALLY, AND FIVE VIRTUALLY MEANS WE'RE JUST PLEASE KEEP AN EYE ON QUORUM.
SO WE NEED TO HAVE SEVEN TOTAL, UM, INCLUDING THOSE ON SCREEN.
UM, AND WE'RE VOTING ONLY ON ONE ITEM TONIGHT, SO MAKE SURE YOU HAVE YOUR RED, YELLOW, AND GREEN ITEMS FOR, UH, THAT ITEM.
[1. Discussion and action to recommend that Council amend the Imagine Austin Comprehensive Plan to add the Equity-Based Preservation Plan, which is a historic preservation plan, to the City’s comprehensive plan. Presentation by Cara Bertron, 512- 974-1446, cara.bertron@austintexas.gov, Planning Department.]
WE'RE GOING TO JUST JUMP RIGHT INTO OUR AGENDA, WHICH IS HEARING, UM, DISCUSSION AND ACTION TO RECOMMEND THAT COUNSEL AMEND THE IMAGINE AUSTIN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO ADD THE EQUITY BASED PRESERVATION PLAN CHAIR.WE HAVE ONE OH CHAIR WILL NOW HEAR.
ARE WE HEARING FROM THE STAFF PRESENTATION? YES.
SO WE'RE GONNA HEAR FROM KARA OR TRU, AND THEN WE'LL GO INTO THOSE SPEAKERS FOR AND AGAINST.
WE'LL NOW BE HEARING FROM STAFF FOR THE PRESENTATION.
KARA BERTRAN PLANNING DEPARTMENT.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE, AND THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME HERE.
TONIGHT I AM GOING TO TALK ABOUT THE EQUITY-BASED PRESERVATION PLAN IS ADVERTISED ON YOUR AGENDA.
THIS HAS BEEN A LONG PLANNING PROCESS SINCE THE SPRING OF 2021, SO ABOUT FOUR, THREE AND A HALF YEARS NOW.
UM, A LOT OF WHAT I'M GOING TO SAY WILL HOPEFULLY SOUND FAMILIAR BECAUSE I SPOKE WITH, I KNOW YOU'VE HAD A LOT GOING ON, BUT I WAS, UH, HERE IN THE SPRING TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT THE DRAFT PRESERVATION PLAN AND INVITE YOU TO PARTICIPATE.
SO I'M GONNA DO A QUICK REVIEW ABOUT THE PLAN, TALK ABOUT THE COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND WHAT WE HEARD, AND, UM, THEN SEE IF Y'ALL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
SO, AS YOU MAY REMEMBER, WE DID NOT HIRE A CONSULTANT TO DEVELOP THIS PLAN.
IT WAS DEVELOPED BY A COMMUNITY WORKING GROUP THAT WAS APPOINTED BY THE HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION IN THE SPRING OF 2021.
YOU CAN SEE A NUMBER OF THOSE MEMBERS ON SCREEN.
THEY CAME FROM ACROSS THE CITY, 19 ZIP CODES AND REFLECT AUSTIN'S RACIAL AND ETHNIC, UH, DIVERSITY.
PEOPLE BROUGHT EXPERTISE IN, CERTAINLY IN HISTORIC PRESERVATION, ALSO IN PLANNING, DEVELOPMENT, ARCHEOLOGY, ARCHITECTURE.
AND THEN THERE WERE OTHER FOLKS WHO DON'T HAVE, UH, FORMAL EXPERTISE OR FORMAL EXPERIENCE WITH HISTORIC PRESERVATION, BUT WHO WERE REALLY CONNECTED TO THEIR NEIGHBORHOODS.
THEIR FAMILIES HAD BEEN IN AUSTIN FOR GENERATIONS AND FELT LIKE THIS WAS A REALLY IMPORTANT PROJECT TO BE PART OF.
SO THIS GROUP WAS SELECTED OUT OF 150 APPLICATIONS AT BY THE LANDMARK COMMISSION.
THESE 26 PEOPLE IN THE WORKING GROUP HEARD FROM
[00:05:01]
275 ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY MEMBERS AS THEY PUT THE PLAN TOGETHER.AND THOSE ARE SUMMARIZED ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THIS SCREEN.
THERE WAS A COMMUNITY HERITAGE SURVEY TO, TO SHAPE THE VISION FOR THE PLAN THREE FOCUS GROUPS, A TECHNICAL ADVISORY GROUP OF CITY STAFF PER USUAL, AND CITY PLANS.
UM, THE LANDMARK COMMISSION HAD A SUBCOMMITTEE THAT OVERSAW THE PROCESS AND WE PARTNERED WITH THE, WITH ULI, AUSTIN AND PRESERVATION AUSTIN ON A TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PANEL LOOKING AT OLDER HOUSING AND AFFORDABILITY.
I'M, AND ALSO THE DISPLACEMENT PREVENTION DIVISION OF THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT ON THAT, HERE'S THE VISION FOR THE PLAN.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION IN AUSTIN ACTIVELY ENGAGES COMMUNITIES IN PROTECTING AND SHARING IMPORTANT PLACES AND STORIES.
PRESERVATION USES THE PAST TO CREATE A SHARED SENSE OF BELONGING AND TO SHAPE AN EQUITABLE, INCLUSIVE, SUSTAINABLE, AND ECONOMICALLY VITAL FUTURE FOR ALL.
AND THAT CAME FROM THE COMMUNITY HERITAGE SURVEY, THE LANGUAGE, THE THEMES, UM, SOME OF THE, SOME OF, I DUNNO IF WE USE DIRECT QUOTES, BUT THAT, THAT, UM, THOSE IDEAS WERE, UM, TAKEN BY THE PRESERVATION PLAN WORKING GROUP AND CREATED, UH, THIS VISION.
THIS IS NOT A, NOT EXACTLY A DIFFERENT VISION FROM HOW WE DO PRESERVATION, BUT IT IS BIGGER.
UM, HISTORICALLY, THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE IN AUSTIN HAS REALLY DONE A PERMIT REVIEW AND HISTORIC ZONING CASES, AND THIS ENVISIONS A MORE ACTIVE ROLE FOR PRESERVATION IN, UM, TO RESPOND TO HELP RESPOND TO PRESSING COMMUNITY NEEDS IN PARTNERSHIP WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
THE PLANET ITSELF HAS 107 RECOMMENDATIONS SPREAD OUT UNDER 14 GOALS.
I'M NOT GONNA RUN THROUGH ALL OF THESE.
I WANT, I FEEL LIKE I ALWAYS WANNA START THIS SLIDE WITHOUT REASSURANCE.
I'M GONNA TALK ABOUT THREE THEMES.
THE FIRST FIVE GOALS ARE UNDER, UH, A THEME CALLED WHAT WE PRESERVE.
GOAL SIX THROUGH EIGHT ARE UNDER THEME CALLED WHO WE WHO PRESERVES.
SO THE RIGHT COLUMN IS UNDER HOW WE PRESERVE KINDA THE NUTS AND BOLTS OF PRESERVATION.
SO UNDER THAT, WHAT WE PRESERVE FIRST THEME, THE BIG IDEA HERE IS REALLY TO THINK BROADLY ABOUT WHAT HISTORY WE ARE PRESERVING.
AND, UM, THIS MENTIONS, YOU KNOW, WORKING MORE ACTIVELY WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS, INTERPRETING WHY THE PLACES WE'RE SPENDING A TON OF ENERGY TO, UH, DESIGNATE AND PRESERVE ARE IMPORTANT SO THAT IT BECOMES A, A BROADER COMMUNITY BENEFIT TO BETTER RECOGNIZE AND PROTECT CULTURAL HERITAGE, UH, LIKE LEGACY BUSINESSES AND MURALS AS WELL AS ARCHITECTURE, UM, ARCHEOLOGICAL RESOURCES, EXCUSE ME.
UM, AND TO REALLY, AS I MENTIONED, CONNECT PRESERVATION TO OTHER COMMUNITY PRIORITIES LIKE COMMUNITY STABILIZATION AND ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY, NOT AS, NOT AS A PANACEA, BUT AS SOMETHING THAT WE CAN BRING SOME TOOLS, UM, TO WORK ON THOSE ISSUES.
THE SECOND THEME IS WHO WE PRESERVES.
AND THE BIG IDEAS HERE ARE REALLY TO INVITE MORE PEOPLE TO PARTICIPATE AND SUPPORT THEM IN THAT PARTICIPATION.
WE STARTED TO ENGAGE NEW PARTNERS AND AUDIENCES AS PART OF OUTREACH AROUND THE PLAN.
I'LL TALK ABOUT THAT IN A FEW SLIDES, BUT THAT WAS REALLY EXCITING.
WE WANT TO MAKE KNOWLEDGE, GETTING KNOWLEDGE AND RESOURCES EASIER, UM, AND SUPPORT FOLKS WHO WERE DOING THE WORK IN VARIOUS WAYS.
YOU KNOW, PEOPLE WHO OWN PROPERTY AND WHO RENT PROPERTY, THE CRAFTSPEOPLE, THE PROFESSIONALS WHO WORK ON THESE BUILDINGS, COMMISSIONERS, AND CITY STAFF AS WELL.
AND THE LAST THEME, HOW WE PRESERVE THE BIG IDEA HERE IS TO BE STRATEGIC AND EFFECTIVE.
RECOGNIZING THAT WE'RE NEVER GOING TO HAVE UNLIMITED RESOURCES.
SO WE WANT TO, UM, MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE USING MODERN STANDARDS FOR, FOR DESIGNATION, UM, TO SUPPORT OUR HISTORIC PROPERTY OWNERS IN WAYS THAT ARE EFFECTIVE AND EQUITABLE TO BE STRATEGIC WITH THE REVIEW THAT WE'RE DOING TO IMPROVE ENFORCEMENT PROCESSES, WHICH IS ALWAYS A CHALLENGE, BUT, BUT AN IMPORTANT ONE.
AND TO IMPLEMENT THE PLAN COLLABORATIVELY, REALLY CONTINUING THE COLLABORATIVE DEVELOPMENT OF THE PLAN.
UM, I THINK THE WHOLE PLAN IS EXTREMELY, UM, INTERESTING AND WELL DONE AND RELEVANT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION HERE ARE, ARE SOME KIND OF A SUBSET OF RECOMMENDATIONS, UM, THAT I'LL HIGHLIGHT THAT ARE, I THINK, ESPECIALLY RELEVANT TO, TO PC'S WORK.
SO, UM, LOOK AT HOW TO, UH, RETAIN EXISTING ADDITIONAL TOOLS FOR RETAINING EXISTING BUILDINGS WHEN PUTTING ADDITIONAL UNITS ON A PROPERTY.
UM, SOME OF THAT WORK HAS, UH, BEEN BEGUN WITH A PRESERVATION BONUS AND WE'LL, WE'LL CONTINUE TO WORK ON AND IMPROVE THAT TO INCENTIVIZE MORE AND SMALLER DWELLING UNITS, THINKING ABOUT MARKET AFFORDABILITY, AS WELL AS THAT SUBSIDIZED AFFORDABILITY SUPPORT THE RETENTION OF OLDER AND HISTORIC COMMERCIAL AND MULTIFAMILY PROPERTIES, SURVEYING BUILDINGS THAT WE HAVEN'T YET SURVEYED TO KNOW WHAT RESOURCES WE HAVE SO WE CAN HOPEFULLY BE MORE PROACTIVE AND THAT PROPERTY OWNERS CAN BE MORE INFORMED TO ENABLE NON-CONTIGUOUS HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND MULTIPLE PROPERTY DESIGNATIONS.
RIGHT NOW, THE CODE, UH, ONLY ALLOWS CONTIGUOUS PROPERTY DESIGNATION.
SO IT HAS TO, IT HAS TO BE ALL PROPERTIES NEXT TO EACH OTHER.
UM, THIS IS AN ALTERNATIVE APPROACH THAT, UH, RECOGNIZES THAT A COMMUNITY'S
[00:10:01]
HISTORY IS RARELY CONTAINED IN ONE SINGLE NEIGHBORHOOD.UM, AND TO LOOK AT A TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS PROGRAM AS A POTENTIAL TOOL FOR, UH, HISTORICAL PROPERTIES.
OKAY, SO NOW I'M GONNA TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AROUND THE PLAN.
UM, THAT WAS THE, THAT'S THE NUTSHELL.
HAPPY TO GO BACK IF Y'ALL HAVE QUESTIONS.
UM, YOU, YOU SAID SMALLER MARKET UNITS.
COULD YOU TEASE THAT OUT FOR ME, PLEASE? SURE.
SO THAT'S, OH, WELL, LET'S LET MS.
BUT WE'RE GONNA HANDLE IT JUST LIKE WE DO OUR, OUR REGULAR.
BUT I WAS JUST RESPONDING TO HER REQUEST, YOU KNOW, REQUEST.
AND I, I'M, I WAS, I SHOULD HAVE BEEN CLEARER.
SO WE DID, UH, FOUR MONTHS OF COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT.
THAT'S THE LAST TIME WE CAME AND SPOKE TO Y'ALL.
UM, WE ENGAGED WELL OVER 2,500 PEOPLE THAT THOSE WERE FOR THE EVENTS WHERE WE WERE COUNTING.
UM, WE DIDN'T TRACK, UH, ALL THE NUMBERS AT ALL THE EVENTS OR OTHER WAYS.
UM, WE MADE MANY PRESENTATIONS TO CITY BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS, COMMUNITY GROUPS AND STAKEHOLDER ORGANIZATIONS ABOUT THE PLAN.
WE DID POPUPS AT COMMUNITY EVENTS AROUND THE CITY.
WE ORGANIZED, UH, FOR EVENTS ABOUT THE PLAN.
WE ALSO DID, UM, THE OTHER THINGS, YOU KNOW, BIG, A BIG SOCIAL MEDIA CAMPAIGN AND, AND MEDIA, UH, BOTH PAID AND ORGANIC.
WE, UH, WROTE A SHORT ARTICLE ABOUT THE PLAN AND SENT IT OUT IN THE AUSTIN UTILITIES NEWSLETTER, UM, TO HOUSEHOLDS ACROSS THE CITY.
SENT MULTIPLE EMAILS TO THE COMMUNITY REGISTRY AND HAD A LIST OF MORE THAN 200 COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS AND STAKEHOLDER ORGANIZATIONS THAT WE PROBABLY OVER REGULARLY SAID, HERE'S WHAT'S GOING ON.
HERE'S THE EVENT THAT'S COMING UP NEXT.
PLEASE, UH, HELP, HELP US GET THE WORD OUT TO YOUR, TO, UH, TO YOUR NETWORKS.
I THINK THE ENGAGEMENT WAS, IT WAS, IT WAS SUCCESSFUL.
AND I THINK ESPECIALLY BECAUSE WE PARTNERED WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS IN SOME REALLY SUBSTANTIAL WAYS.
SO WE WORKED WITH NINE COMMUNITY MEMBERS AS PAID AMBASSADORS AND ASKED THEM TO TALK TO THEIR NETWORKS ABOUT THE PLAN AND TO INVITE PEOPLE TO GIVE FEEDBACK.
WE AWARDED ALSO FIVE, $5,000 MINI GRANTS TO COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS TO GET THE WORD OUT TO THEIR NETWORKS AND, UM, USING METHODS THAT THEY PROPOSE.
SO THOSE ORGANIZATIONS WERE, WERE ABLE TO SAY, HERE'S HOW TO BEST REACH THE PEOPLE WHO, WHO WE ALREADY KNOW.
AND TO DO THAT, HERE'S A SUMMARY OF WHO WE HEARD FROM.
SO MOST PEOPLE PARTICIPATED IN THE PLANNING PROCESS ACTIVELY THROUGH A COMMUNITY SURVEY THAT WAS ONLINE OR ON PAPER.
UM, WHEN WE LOOK AT THE PERCENTAGE OF SURVEY RESPONDENTS FOR THESE HISTORICALLY MARGINALIZED COMMUNITIES COMPARED TO AUSTIN AS A WHOLE, YOU CAN SEE THAT WE HAD A ROUGHLY EQUAL PROPORTION OF, OF PEOPLE OF COLOR AS THE CITY AS A WHOLE, WHICH WAS REALLY EXCITING.
AND, AND NOT TYPICAL FOR, FOR ALWAYS WHO SHOWS UP TO HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION MEETINGS.
UM, THERE WAS A MUCH HIGHER SHARE OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES IN THE LGBTQA PLUS COMMUNITIES THAN THE CITY AS A WHOLE.
UM, A LOWER SHARE OF RENTERS, UM, NEARLY 30% STILL, STILL PRETTY GOOD FOR A CITY PLAN, BUT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE WANT TO KEEP WORKING ON AS WE IMPLEMENT.
THE PLAN IS THINKING ABOUT HOW TO, HOW TO WORK WITH RENTERS.
UM, AND THAT IMPLEMENTATION, YOU CAN SEE PEOPLE FROM ACROSS THE CITY, UH, RESPONDED TO THE SURVEY, THE ZIP CODE WITH THE ZIP CODE MAP ON THE LOWER RIGHT HAND CORNER.
AND ON THE UPPER RIGHT HAND CORNER, YOU CAN SEE THAT WE HEARD FROM A LOT OF LONG TIME RESIDENTS.
UM, 60%, A LITTLE OVER 60% HAD LIVED IN AUSTIN FOR MORE THAN 20 YEARS, UM, AS WELL AS NEWER, NEWER RESIDENTS.
HERE'S A SUMMARY OF WHAT WE HEARD THE SURVEY INCLUDE, INCLUDED A LIST OF COMMUNITY PRIORITIES THAT WE AGGREGATED FROM THE PLAN GOALS.
AND THE QUICK TAKEAWAY FROM THIS SLIDE IS THAT PEOPLE SAID ALL OF THESE THINGS ARE IMPORTANT.
UM, THE LOWEST, THAT LOWEST KIND OF IMPORTANT SCORE WAS 73%, WHICH IS PRETTY HIGH.
WHEN WE ASKED WHAT WE SHOULD START WORKING ON FIRST, UM, JUST TO GET A SENSE OF PEOPLE'S PRIORITIES, THE PLURALITY OF FOLKS, THE MAJORITY OF FOLKS ACTUALLY SAID, WE SHOULD START, UH, MAKING SURE THAT WE SHOULD MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE IN BUSINESSES CAN AFFORD TO STAY IN PLACE.
AND THAT'S NOT A SURPRISE THAT REFLECTS THE, THE SITUATION IN THE CITY.
ANOTHER 20% SAID THAT, UH, HELP KEEP AUSTIN'S PHYSICAL LANDSCAPE FEELING LIKE AUSTIN.
I THINK THAT THAT REALLY CHECKS, THAT IS A, A GOOD REALITY CHECK, UM, WITH WHAT WE LIKE, WHAT WE ALL KNOW.
WE ALSO GOT SPECIFIC COMMENTS ON THE DRAFT PLAN.
ABOUT HALF OF THOSE WERE ACTIONABLE, MEANING THAT ACTION WAS REQUESTED.
UH, THEY'RE IN THE SCOPE OF THE PLAN AND THEY'RE ALLOWABLE, ALLOWABLE BY CITY CODE.
HALF THE RECOMMENDATIONS IN THE DRAFT PLAN WERE REVISED BASED ON COMMUNITY FEEDBACK.
UM, SO THERE WERE, WERE REAL CHANGES MADE AND SOME NEW RECOMMENDATIONS WERE ADDED.
UM, THE LIST OF INCLUDED HERE INCLUDES HISTORIC CEMETERIES, ENERGY EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS,
[00:15:01]
YOU KNOW, BUILDING MAINTENANCE EDUCATION AND TRAINING AND SUPPORT FOR HERITAGE TOURISM SITES.SEE, I THINK, YES, HERE'S THE PRESERVATION PLAN TIMELINE IN A NUTSHELL.
SO THE PRESERVATION PLAN WORKING GROUP, UH, MET OVER THE COURSE OF 12 MONTHS FROM 20 20, 20 20, OH MY GOSH.
UM, THEY PRESENTED TO THE DRAFT PLAN TO THE LANDMARK COMMISSION IN THAT FALL.
UM, AND AT THAT TIME, COUNCIL FUNDED, UM, ALLOCATED FUNDING FOR OUTREACH IN A DEDICATED STAFF POSITION, WHICH IS THE POSITION THAT I HOLD NOW.
IT TOOK US A LITTLE WHILE TO GET THE INFRASTRUCTURE IN PLACE TO HIRE, UH, FOR THIS POSITION AND ALSO TO HIRE A CONSULTANT.
SO IN THE MEANTIME, WE DID A, A VERY, UM, LOW KEY NO BUDGET, UH, CAMPAIGN TO RAISE AWARENESS AND TO TRY TO GET MORE FOLKS TO THINK MAYBE PRESERVATION IS SOMETHING THAT, THAT THEY'RE INTERESTED IN TRYING MAKE THE TENT BIGGER BEFORE WE STARTED THE RODEO.
UM, THEN WE DID THAT OUTREACH, UH, INTENSIVE OUTREACH AND ENGAGEMENT THIS SPRING, AS I MENTIONED, UM, GETTING FEEDBACK ON THE DRAFT PLAN FROM COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
AND THIS SUMMER WE, UM, FACILITATED A SERIES OF MEETINGS BETWEEN THE PRESERVATION PLAN WORKING GROUP THAT DEVELOPED THE PLAN AND THE HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION'S PRESERVATION PLAN COMMITTEE TO REVISE THE PLAN TO LOOK AT THAT COMMUNITY FEEDBACK AND MAKE REVISIONS.
SO, UM, BEEN A COLLABORATIVE PROCESS THROUGHOUT.
WE ARE DOING CITY BOARD AND COMMISSION BRIEFINGS NOW.
UM, WHAT I DIDN'T INCLUDE IN THIS TIMELINE WAS THAT ON SEPTEMBER 12TH, COUNCIL INITIATED AN AMENDMENT TO THE IMAGINE AUSTIN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AS STEP ONE OF THIS TWO STEP PROCESS.
UM, AND WE ARE BEFORE WE WENT TO THE, UM, COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, PLAN JOINT COMMITTEE A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO TO GET A RECOMMENDATION.
UM, AND WE ARE HERE, I AM HERE, UH, TONIGHT TO, UM, TALK ABOUT NEXT STEPS AND THEN GIVE YOU A SLIDE WITH THE, WHAT WE'RE HOPING THE THE PLANNING COMMISSION WILL DO, UH, TONIGHT.
UM, WHEN THE PLAN IS ADOPT, WELL HOPEFULLY COUNCIL WILL ADOPT THE PLAN.
AND WHEN THE PLAN IS ADOPTED, WE HAVE A, AN, UM, A SORT OF ROADMAP FOR AN IMPLEMENTATION PLAN TO DO WHAT WE CAN WITH THE RESOURCES THAT WE HAVE.
SO START WORKING ON THINGS IMMEDIATELY, UH, LAY THE GROUNDWORK FOR RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WILL REQUIRE ADDITIONAL RESOURCES, WHETHER THAT'S FUNDING OR STAFF, AND START WORKING ON THOSE, HOPEFULLY IN THE NEXT FISCAL YEAR, IN ABOUT A YEAR, WE'LL HAVE A PUBLIC DASHBOARD, UM, TO TRACK PROGRESS ON THE PLAN.
WE'LL CONTINUE WORKING WITH OTHER CITY DEPARTMENTS ON THE PLAN, UM, TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR WORK SUPPORTS THEIRS AND, AND HOPEFULLY VICE VERSA.
AND WE'LL CONTINUE COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND PARTNERSHIP BUILDING.
I THINK THAT'S BEEN, THAT'S BEEN THE BACKBONE OF THIS, OF THIS WHOLE PROCESS AND THE HEART AND ALL OF THE ESSENTIAL ORGANS, AND THAT'S A REALLY PRIORITY FOR US MOVING FORWARD.
SO TONIGHT THE RECOMMENDED PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION WOULD BE, UM, FOR YOU TO RECOMMEND THAT COUNCIL AMEND THE IMAGINE AUSTIN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO ADD THE EQUITY BASED PRESERVATION PLAN TO THE CITY'S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
UM, AND THEN IT, AFTER THAT POINT, UH, WE HOPE TO, TO GO TO COUNCIL ON NOVEMBER 21ST, AND THEN THEY WOULD ADOPT THE PLAN AND AMEND IMAGINE AUSTIN, TO MAKE THIS AN ELEMENT OF THE PLAN.
AND THAT IS, THAT'S WHAT I HAVE.
SO WE'RE GONNA HEAR FROM SPEAKERS, UM, IN SUPPORT OF, AND OPPOSED TO, AND, UM, THEN WE'LL GET INTO QUESTIONS WITH THE COMMISSION.
AND I WANNA RECOGNIZE COMMISSIONER JOHNSON AND OUR EX OFFICIO, BOA CHAIR CO.
ALRIGHT, MS. GARCIA CHAIR, WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER SIGNED UP IN OPPOSITION.
ANGELA, YOU WILL HAVE THREE MINUTES.
ANGELA GARZA REPRESENTING, UM, FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT, UM, IN AUSTIN, TEXAS.
AND ONCE AGAIN, WE HAVE TO VOTE.
DOESN'T NECESSARILY MEAN THAT WE DON'T AGREE WITH THE PROGRAM, BUT I WOULD, UM, ASK THAT YOU THINK ABOUT SOME FRIENDLY REQUIREMENTS.
UM, WHEN I READ OVER THE DOCUMENT AND THE 98 PAGES, IT WAS A PLEASURE TO MEET ALL THE PEOPLE THAT WORKED ON THIS.
UM, DIANA DEAN DID, UM, REPRESENT EAST MLK.
THEY WORKED REALLY HARD TO GET THIS INFORMATION, BUT WHAT I DON'T SEE IN THE ACTUAL, UM, PLAN IS I DON'T SEE SOLID QUID PRO QUO.
LIKE, WHAT ARE WE GETTING FOR THAT RIGHT NOW? SO, FOR EXAMPLE, WE'RE HITTING ROADBLOCKS WITH GETTING NATIONAL PRESERVATION AS WELL.
IT'S COSTLY FOR SOME OF THE PEOPLE OUT THERE.
AND THEN BY THE TIME THEY FIND OUT THAT THEY'RE GOING TO GET THAT OR NOT GET THAT, THEY'VE ALREADY INVESTED SOME OF THAT MONEY AND THEN THEY FIND OUT THEY'RE NOT BEING APPROVED FOR IT.
SO I'M, I'M REALLY ASKING FOR A FRIENDLY, UM, REQUIREMENT TO, CAN WE COME UP WITH A SOLUTION THAT'S GONNA BE A LITTLE BIT BETTER PROCESS FOR THEM SO THAT THEY CAN FIGURE OUT AHEAD OF SCHEDULE IF THEY'RE GOING, CAN THEY, UM, ACTUALLY GET APPROVED FOR THE NATIONAL DESIGNATION BECAUSE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PROPERTY TAXES THERE AS WELL THAT THEY CAN GET APPROVED
[00:20:01]
FOR.UM, ALSO THE SECOND THING IS THAT WE, I I NOTICED ON HERE THAT, UM, WE HAVE AUSTIN BOARD OF REALTORS WHERE THEY'RE ACTUALLY GETTING TRAINED FOR THIS.
NOW, LET ME TELL YOU WHY THAT'S NOT A GOOD IDEA.
WE LIKE WHAT THIS GROUP IS DOING, AND I THINK THEY NEED TO BE A CHECKPOINT TO SEE IF OUR HOMEOWNERS HAVE MET ALL THE OPPORTUNITIES.
UM, THE OPPORTUNITIES OF DO, HAVE YOU SEEN ALL YOUR RESOURCES AND DO YOU KNOW WHAT YOUR RESOURCES ARE? AND SIMILAR TO THE, TO THE POINT OF WHEN WE DO A CHECKPOINT, WHEN A PROPERTY IS GOING DOWN AND DEMO DEMOLISHED FOR 40 YEARS, I'M A THIRD GENERATION HERE IN AUSTIN, TEXAS.
WE NEED TO HAVE THAT SAME CHECKPOINT, BUT THEY NEED THE STAFF TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT AND BE ABLE TO SUPPORT THAT.
AND THEN THEY GIVE THE CLEARANCE, THE CLEARANCE TO THE ACTUAL AUSTIN BOARD OF REALTORS IF Y'ALL DECIDE THAT.
BUT IT'S A NONPROFIT THAT LEADS TO PROFIT.
SO THAT KIND OF, IT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE RIGHT NOW UNLESS WE KNOW FOR SURE THAT THE ACTUAL PEOPLE HAVE SAID, I KNOW ABOUT ALL MY OPTIONS.
I'M DECLINING ALL MY OPTIONS IN THE AUSTIN, TEXAS.
WE JUST WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT YOU HAVE THESE, 'CAUSE YOU'VE BEEN HERE LONG, AND WE WANNA MAKE SURE THAT YOU HAVE OPTIONS TO STAY IN THE CITY.
SO THESE ARE OTHER OPTIONS WE'RE JUST NOT SEEING LIKE EXACTLY.
AND I KNOW THAT, UM, I'M SORRY, YOUR NAME AGAIN, I APOLOGIZE.
UM, SHE EXPLAINED THAT THERE, THEY'RE STILL GONNA CONTINUE WORKING ON THIS, BUT I JUST SAW A LOT OF THINGS WHERE WE'RE NOT SEEING WHAT WE'RE GETTING FOR THAT AQUI PRO QUO.
AND I'M NOT A LAWYER, BUT I WAS READING 98 PAGES AND I'M NOT SEEING EXACTLY WHAT OUR FAMILIES ARE GETTING IN RETURN IN THIS PROGRAM.
STILL APPRECIATE EVERYBODY PUTTING THEIR INPUT AND THEIR HARD WORK, BUT I JUST THINK THAT WE NEED SOME FRIENDLY ADD-ONS THAT CAN WE LOOK INTO THESE MATTERS THAT WILL MAKE IT A LITTLE BIT EASIER FOR PEOPLE TO GO THROUGH THESE PROCESSES THAT BE, THAT ARE TEDIOUS AND THEN THEY'RE BEING DECLINED FOR THESE PROCESSES AFTER THEY HAVE INVESTED MONEY AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HEARING ME TONIGHT.
OH, YOU HAVE A AND THAT'S OUR ONLY SPEAKER? YES.
UM, MS. BERTRAN, DID YOU WANT TO, I, IT WOULD BE A QUOTE UNQUOTE REBUTTAL, BUT DID YOU WANT TO MAKE ANY FINAL REMARKS AS THE, THE CITY'S THE APPLICANT ON THIS? UM, I THINK I AGREE WITH A LOT OF WHAT MU GARZA SAID ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT PEOPLE HAVE INFORMATION EARLY AND REALLY CLEAR INFORMATION AND KNOW THEIR, CERTAINLY THEIR OPTIONS ABOUT HISTORIC DESIGNATION, WHICH IS WHAT WE CAN CONTROL.
UM, SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT I THINK THE PLAN REFERENCES IN A VERY GENERAL WAY ABOUT PROVIDING MORE INFORMATION AND, AND ALSO LOWERING HISTORIC ZONING APPLICATION FEES.
SO, UM, I THINK THAT, UH, YEAH, SUPPORT THAT, UM, IN TERMS OF, OF SPECIFICS, THAT WILL BE, THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE PLAN ON WORKING ON IMPLEMENTATION.
YOU KNOW, IT'S KIND OF A BALANCING ACT WITH A CITYWIDE PLAN THAT COVERS A LOT OF GROUND AS TO HOW MANY, HOW MANY SPECIFICS WE CAN INCLUDE.
AND, AND, UM, I THINK FOR A LOT OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS IN HERE, REALLY LAYING OUT A ROADMAP FOR, FOR PRACTICAL IMPLEMENTATION REQUIRES A LOT MORE INVOLVED STAKEHOLDER CONVERSATIONS THAN WE HAD THE TIME TO DO IN THE PLANNING PROCESS IN THE YEAR LONG PLANNING PROCESS.
SO, UM, APPRECIATE HER, UM, MS. GARZA'S, UH, REVIEW AND THOUGHTFUL COMMENTS.
WELL, UM, I'M LOOKING FOR A MOTION AND A SECOND TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
AND SECOND BY COMMISSIONER JOHNSON, UNLESS THERE IS OPPOSITION TO THAT, THAT MOTION PASSES.
AND I'M RECOGNIZING COMMISSIONER MARIA RAMIREZ AND COMMISSIONER COX HAVE JOINED US, AND I'LL GO INTO QUESTIONS AS SEEN.
COMMISSIONER HAYNES, LET'S DIVE IN.
UM, AS MANY OF YOU KNOW, I'M THE, I'M THE CHAIR OF THE COMBINED, UH, THE COMBINED PLANNING JOINT COMMITTEE.
AND I WILL TELL YOU, Y'ALL KNOW, I'M AS CRITICAL OF STAFF AS ANYBODY, BUT MS. BERTRAND, UM, AND HER STAFF CAME AND PRESENTED TO, UM, CPJC AND TOOK OUR INPUT AND THEN, UH, MADE SOME TWEAKS AND REFINED AND CAME BACK.
AND, UM, I AM A HUNDRED PERCENT BEHIND WHAT SHE'S DONE.
UM, I, I, I HEAR MS. GARCIA, UM, IT, IT IS NOT PERFECT BY ANY STRETCH OF THE IMAGINATION, BUT WE CANNOT LET THE GOOD GET IN, GET IN THE WAY OF THE PERFECT.
AND, UM, UM, I, I'M, I'M FULLY SUPPORTIVE AND I HOPE ALL THE COMMISSIONERS ARE AS WELL.
I, UH, THIS, THIS NEEDS TO BE PASSED AND NEEDS TO BE PART OF THE IMAGINE AUSTIN PLAN, SO THANKS.
NEXT QUESTION, COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS, I TOO, UH, SHARE ADAM HAYNES'S, UM, UH, UH, SENSIBILITIES ABOUT THE PLAN.
I, I CONGRATULATE THE WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE AND
[00:25:01]
THE OUTREACH THAT YOU'VE HAD IN THIS COMMUNITY AND DRAFTING THIS PLAN BECAUSE I THINK IT'S OVERDUE.AND, UM, SO I'M REALLY HAPPY TO SEE IT.
VERY HAPPY TO SEE IT, AND, AND I AGREE THAT WE SHOULD NOT LET THE, UH, PERFECT, YOU KNOW, GET IN THE WAY OF THE GOOD.
THE ONE THING YOU, I, I KIND OF DID NOT GET THE WHOLE CONTEXT WHEN YOU MENTIONED THE MARKET RATE HOUSING, SO I DON'T KNOW WHETHER IT WAS JUST, I DIDN'T HEAR THE WHOLE THING, BUT IF YOU WOULD TEASE THAT OUT AGAIN FOR ME, I WOULD REALLY APPRECIATE THAT.
MM-HMM,
SO IT'S UNDER THE, UH, STABILIZED COMMUNITY'S GOALS AND GOAL, AND THE RECOMMENDATION IS TO INCENTIVIZE, EXCUSE ME, INCENTIVIZE MORE SMALLER DWELLING UNITS TO PROVIDE MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING WHILE STEWARDING NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER.
SO THINKING ABOUT WHAT WE WOULD HAD PREVIOUSLY CALLED A ADUS, SO ADDING, ADDING UNITS, UM, IN THE CONTEXT OF, OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD FABRIC AND, UM, WHAT THE, HOW DOES THAT TIE BACK TO HISTORIC PRESERVATION? YEAH, SO THIS, THE PRESERVATION PLAN, UM, IT, IT'S A LITTLE BIT BIGGER THAN A A, IT AIMS TO BE A LITTLE BIT BIGGER THAN A, A TRADITIONAL PRESERVATION PLAN THAT IT TALKS ABOUT PEOPLE AND THE VALUE THAT PEOPLE ADD TO COMMUNITY AND, AND TO PLACES.
UM, SO IT THINKS ABOUT THAT, THAT INTANGIBLE HERITAGE.
UM, PARTICULARLY UNDER THE STABILIZED COMMUNITY'S GOAL.
IT ALSO LOOKS AT THE BENEFITS OF OLDER BUILDINGS, UM, NOT JUST OUR DESIGNATED LANDMARKS AND DISTRICTS.
NOT THAT THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE IS NOT SEEKING TO REGULATE MORE THAN OUR LANDMARKS AND DISTRICTS, BUT HOW CAN WE WORK WITH OTHER DEPARTMENTS TO MAKE IT EASIER TO RETAIN OLDER BUILDINGS IF, OR TO MAKE IT MORE OF A, A CHOICE, UM, TO KEEP THOSE LANDSCAPES NOT IN A CAPITAL H HISTORIC WAY, BUT IN A WAY THAT, UM, RETAINS MORE OLDER HOUSING THAT'S OFTEN SMALLER AND MORE MARKET AFFORDABLE THAN, THAN NEWER HOUSING, UM, WHILE ADDING DENSITY, YOU KNOW, WHILE SUPPORTING THOSE LONGTIME PROPERTY OWNERS.
AND I THINK MY LAST QUESTION ON, ON THAT TOPIC ABOUT THE SMALLER MARKET RATE, MARKET RATE UNITS, AND, EXCUSE ME, I HAD DENTAL SURGERY, SO I'M STRUGGLING A LITTLE BIT.
I'M IN THE PEAK OF THE PAIN PERIOD.
SO, UM, DID IT LOOK AT ANY KIND OF AFFORDABILITY ASSOCIATED WITH THOSE UNITS? THE PLAN IN WE ARE, THE PLAN ITSELF DID NOT, WE LOOKED AT THE AUSTIN HOUSING ANALYSIS THAT UT COMPLETED A FEW YEARS AGO, WHICH, WHICH REALLY CHEWED THROUGH, UH, REAMS OF DATA, UM, TO LOOK AT AFFORDABILITY.
UM, WE ALSO ARE WORKING ON A, WORKING ON, WE'RE AT THE VERY LAST STAGES OF FINALIZING, UM, AN ANALYSIS OF, OF OLDER BUILDINGS AND AFFORDABILITY THAT I EXPECT TO HAVE COMPLETED SOON.
IT'S A PARALLEL PROCESS WITH THIS PLAN.
OTHER QUESTIONS? MR. SKIDMORE? DID I SEE YOUR HANDS? NO.
UM, YES, I JUST HAD TWO QUICK QUESTIONS, JUST A KIND OF CLARIFY.
UM, THERE WAS, UH, ON ONE OF YOUR RECOMMENDATIONS THOUGHT WOULD BE PARTICULARLY INTERESTING TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION WAS NUMBER 81 RELATING TO THE TRANSFER DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS.
AND I WAS JUST WONDERING IF YOU COULD EXPLAIN THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE AND PERHAPS SPEAK TO HOW YOU THOUGHT THAT FIT INTO THIS PLAN? YES, THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY.
I, I ALMOST TALKED ABOUT IT MORE ON THAT SLIDE, AND THEN I, I CHOSE NOT TO, SO I'M GLAD TO CIRCLE BACK.
SO, UM, AS Y'ALL PROBABLY KNOW, BUT TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE'S ON THE SAME PAGE, TRANSFERS OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS ARE BASICALLY WHEN YOU, UM, HAVE A BUILDING THAT DOES NOT MAX OUT THE ZONING ENTITLEMENTS AND YOU'RE ABLE TO SELL THE AIR RIGHTS ON TOP OF IT.
AND THEN THOSE AIR RIGHTS CAN BE SOLD IN SOME CITIES TDR PROGRAMS, THEY CAN BE SOLD TO A BUILDING RIGHT NEXT TO OR KITTY CORNER TO THAT BUILDING.
IN SOME CITIES, THERE ARE, UM, KIND OF SENDING ZONES, WHICH ARE THOSE AREAS WHERE THE AIR RIGHTS CAN BE SOLD, AND THEN RECEIVING ZONES, WHICH ARE AREAS WHERE THOSE AREAS, UH, WHERE THE AIR RIGHTS CAN BE PURCHASED TO GO ABOVE WHAT IS ENTITLED BY ZONING.
SO THE, WE HAVE BEEN LOOKING AT TDRS FOR, FOR A NUMBER OF, OF YEARS NOW, BECAUSE AUSTIN'S DOWN, PARTICULARLY OUR DOWNTOWN HISTORIC LANDMARKS, ARE VERY PETITE COMPARED TO THE ZONING ENTITLEMENTS.
AND SO WE'VE, WE HAVE A LOT OF, UM, REALLY DEDICATED HISTORIC PROPERTY OWNERS.
BUT THE IDEA BEHIND TDRS IS THAT THEY PROVIDE RESOURCES THAT THOSE PROPERTY OWNERS CAN REINVEST IN THEIR BUILDINGS
[00:30:01]
IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO, BUT DON'T ASK THEM.UM, IT'S A WAY, IT'S A TOOL WHERE PRIVATE FUNDING IS USED, UM, SO THAT PROPERTY OWNERS DON'T HAVE TO MAKE A FINANCIAL SACRIFICE TO OWN A SMALLER HISTORIC BUILDING.
SO THIS CALLS FOR, UH, BASICALLY A MARKET ANALYSIS OF, OF TDRS TO SEE IS THIS A TOOL THAT WOULD WORK IN AUSTIN? UM, WHERE WOULD IT WORK? WHAT WOULD IT LOOK LIKE? WHAT WOULD, WHAT SHOULD THE MECHANICS LOOK LIKE? THAT'D BE THE NEXT BIG STEP.
AND THAT'S, THAT'S ACTUALLY ONE OF THE FIRST ITEMS IN, UM, IN IMPLEMENTATION THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT.
AND JUST AS A MATTER OF CURIOSITY, WE'VE SEEN THESE TYPES OF PROGRAMS WORK TO HELP PRESERVATION IN OTHER CITIES, IS THAT CORRECT? 'CAUSE AUSTIN DOESN'T HAVE A PROGRAM LIKE THAT CURRENTLY.
AND THEN I DID HAVE ONE OTHER FOLLOW UP QUESTION, IF I HAVE ADDITIONAL TIME.
AND I GUESS I WAS JUST CURIOUS, UM, REGARDING THE RECOMMENDATIONS OR THOUGHTS YOU ALL HAVE HAVING GONE THROUGH ALL OF THIS WONDERFUL WORK, UM, REGARDING THE TAX INCENTIVES FOR HISTORICAL PRESERVATION, BECAUSE I KNOW THAT THAT'S SOMETHING THAT OFTEN IS A CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE, PRO AND CON, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS WHERE YOU FELT THAT FOLKS AND OPINIONS ENDED UP ON THAT PARTICULAR ITEM RELATED TO THIS.
SO THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION.
THE PRESERVATION PLAN INCLUDES A NUMBER OF RECOMMENDATIONS THAT, THAT RECOMMEND ASSESSMENT OF AND POTENTIAL CHANGES TO THE HISTORIC TAX INCENTIVES.
UM, IN SOME WAYS EXPANDING WHAT'S AVAILABLE.
SO, UH, A NEW, UM, POTENTIALLY A NEW TIME-LIMITED TAX ABATEMENT FOR NEW LANDMARKS AND DISTRICTS, A 10, KIND OF A 10 YEAR, UM, A 10 YEAR ABATEMENT, WHICH COULD BE BOTH A PRESERVATION AND AN ANTI DISPLACEMENT INCENTIVE.
UM, EXPANDING THE EX OUR EXISTING REHABILITATION TAX ABATEMENT THAT WE HAVE RIGHT NOW IN HISTORIC DISTRICTS TO BE A LITTLE BIT MORE GENEROUS TO HELP PEOPLE RECOUP THE COST OF MONEY THAT THEY'RE PUTTING INTO THEIR PROPERTIES AND EXPANDING IT TO HISTORIC LANDMARKS.
UM, AND, UM, POTENTIALLY SHIFTING TOWARDS THAT PROJECT BASED APPROACH AS LANDMARK OWNERSHIP CHANGES, UM, FROM THE ANNUAL TAX EXEMPTION.
BUT THAT WOULD BE THE PLAN SAYS, DO A CAREFUL ASSESSMENT FIRST.
LOOK AT WHAT, LOOK AT AT WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING, LOOK AT THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS PROGRAM, WHICH COULD BE A MAJOR INCENTIVE, AND MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE STILL REALLY SUPPORTING OUR HISTORIC PROPERTY OWNERS IN A WAY THAT'S EFFECTIVE, UM, THROUGH THESE CHANGES.
APPRECIATE THOSE DETAILED RESPONSES.
ALRIGHT, OTHER QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER ANDERSON, SUPER QUICK.
UM, SO I, THE, THE COUPLE OF FOLKS I'VE BOUNCED THIS OFF OF SHARED THAT UNTIL AUSTIN HAS A WORKING TRANSFER DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS PROGRAM THAT WE'RE ALWAYS GOING TO BE JUST WANTING AND WISHING AND KIND OF DROPPING THE BALL IN, IN PLACES WHERE WE WOULDN'T NEED TO OTHERWISE.
'CAUSE THERE'S SO MUCH VALUE IN THEM.
SO WHAT, WHAT CAN THIS BODY DO TO KINDA HELP THIS ALONG WITH A REALLY GOOD PROGRAM AND TRY AND GET BEHIND SOMETHING THAT HELPS TO KEEP, GET THAT GOING INSTEAD OF IT JUST BEING A, WOULDN'T IT BE GREAT IF, THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION.
I, I THINK THAT, UM, IF THIS BODY WANTS TO HAVE A, A STRONG VOICE, I THINK, UM, IT COULD INCLUDE THAT PARTICULAR RECOMMENDATION AS, AS PART OF, UH, A RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL NOW OR, OR IN, IN THE FUTURE.
I THINK THAT'S, THAT'S WHAT I'M AWARE OF, BUT I'M OPEN TO, IF Y'ALL HAVE PARADES WITH SIGNS AND THINGS, I WOULD LOVE TO COME SEE THAT.
AND WHEN YOU SAID, UH, OF COURSE YOU BROUGHT THIS THROUGH COJC, UM, CAN YOU TALK ABOUT ANY RECOMMENDATIONS THAT COJC MAY HAVE HAD? SURE.
SO, UM, SOME OF THE, THE DISCUSSIONS THAT WE HAD AT THE JOINT COMMITTEE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT, UM, THE TERM EQUITY AND KIND OF, ITS ITS USE IN THE TITLE OF THE PLAN AND, AND WANTING TO, IT WAS A GOOD DISCUSSION ABOUT HOW WE'VE TRIED TO USE INTEGRATE EQUITY THROUGHOUT THE PROCESS, NOT JUST PUT IT ON THE TITLE OF THE PLAN SO THAT IT SOUNDS GOOD.
UM, WE TALKED ABOUT, UH, THE URGENCY OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION, UM, WORK, I'M SORRY, TO BE CLEAR.
I, I'M, I'M MAINLY LOOKING FOR ANY, UH, RECOMMENDATIONS AS FAR AS PAST AMENDMENTS.
SO WE DID NOT, WE TALKED ABOUT A NUMBER OF, OF THINGS WE WEREN'T, I DON'T REMEMBER SPECIFIC CHANGES THAT WERE REQUESTED SO MUCH AS CLARIFICATIONS THAT WE, THAT WE DISCUSSED.
UM, AND I THINK AT THIS, AT THIS POINT WITH THE PLAN, YOU KNOW, GETTING BOARD AND COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONS, UM, ANY CHANGES WOULD GO THROUGH THAT, THAT RECOMMENDATION PROCESS.
UM, COMMISSIONERS IN THAT JOINT IN THE COMMITTEE MAY RECALL MORE CLEARLY THAN, THAN I DO.
[00:35:01]
I THINK WE'RE GOOD.UM, JUST, UM, CAN YOU DESCRIBE THE, THE VISION FOR HOW THIS PLAN WILL BE UPDATED? YOU MENTIONED A, UM, A DASHBOARD OR IS THIS GOING TO LIVE ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE AND IT WILL BE ACTIVELY UPDATED AT CERTAIN TIMES OF THE YEAR? YES, THANK YOU.
SO WE EXPECT TO HAVE A, A REGULARLY UPDATED DASHBOARD.
UM, WE'VE BEEN TALKING TO THE, UH, CLIMATE EQUITY PLAN TEAM AND THE OFFICE OF SUSTAINABILITY AND LOOKING AT THEIR DASHBOARD, WHICH IS I THINK, UH, MAYBE DETAILED TOOL LEVEL WE WILL NOT HAVE.
BUT LOOKING AT THAT AS A MODEL AND TALKING TO THEM ABOUT HOW OFTEN THEY'RE UPDATING IT.
UM, AND THEY'RE UPDATING IT, UH, ON A, A VERY REGULAR BASIS, YOU KNOW, UM, PRETTY FREQUENTLY, UM, FOR THE DATA AND THEN FOR, UH, PROJECTS THAT INVOLVE OTHER DEPARTMENTS, I THINK THEY ARE SWITCHING TO AN EVERY OTHER YEAR UPDATES JUST BECAUSE GETTING THOSE TEXT UP TEXT UPDATES TAKES A VERY LONG TIME.
UM, SO THINKING ABOUT, ABOUT THAT KIND OF MODEL WHERE THINGS THAT ARE UNDER OUR CONTROL THAT WE'RE TRACKING, THAT WE'RE ABLE TO UPDATE, UM, PRETTY FREQUENTLY.
AND, UM, DOING, DOING OTHER COLLABORATIVE THINGS AS WE'RE, AS WE'RE ABLE TO, UM, THE PLAN RECOMMENDS A REPLACING ITSELF OR A MAJOR UPDATE IN 10 YEARS.
WE ARE HOPING THAT, UM, IT ALSO, UH, REQUESTS ANNUAL REPORTS, WHICH WOULD OF COURSE BE REFLECTED IN THE DASHBOARD AND BE PUBLIC.
UM, WE'RE HOPING FOR A, A MAJOR CONSIDERATION IN FIVE YEARS JUST TO KIND OF TAKE A LOOK AT IT AND SAY, IS THIS STILL MEETING OUR NEEDS? WHAT NEEDS TO BE, WHAT NEEDS TO BE ADJUSTED? GIVEN WHAT WE'VE LEARNED THAT'S NOT REWRITING THE PLAN.
UM, BUT ISN'T TO THAT 10 YEAR MARK YET.
AND ONE MORE QUESTION TOO, UH, MS. GARZA'S, UM, QUESTION ABOUT HOW DOES THE PLAN, OR ARE THERE POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE PLAN THAT WERE DISCUSSED ABOUT HOW TO INFORM HOMEOWNER, HOMEOWNERS OF ALL OF THEIR OPTIONS SO THAT IT'S CRYSTAL CLEAR BEFORE THEN MOVING FORWARD? I DON'T THINK THE LANGUAGE IS THAT SPECIFIC.
THERE'S A LOT OF GENERAL, THERE NOT A LOT.
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF RECOMMENDATIONS THAT SPEAK TO THE NEED TO, UM, REACH COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHERE THEY ARE, YOU KNOW, LIKE TALK TO COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO AREN'T CALLING THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE, UM, TO HAVE CLEARER, UM, MORE ACCESSIBLE INFORMATION FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT USED TO HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROCESSES, UM, TO WORK WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS ON A CONTINUING COMMUNITY AMBASSADOR PROGRAM, WHICH WOULD BE DEPENDENT ON RESOURCES, BUT THINGS LIKE THAT THAT I THINK, UM,
OTHER QUESTIONS? ALRIGHT, UM, LOOKING FOR A MOTION AND, UM, I'M HAPPY TO, TO START THE MOTION.
UM, I WOULD RECOMMEND THAT THE CITY COUNCIL AMEND THE IMAGINE AUSTIN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO ADD THE EQUITY BASED PRESERVATION PLAN TO THE COMP PLAN.
SECOND, SECOND, MY COMMISSIONER HANEY, UM, SPEAKING TO IT, I KNOW THAT THERE'S BEEN YEARS AND YEARS OF WORK, LOTS OF ENGAGEMENT.
I MEAN, WHAT WAS JUST OUTLINED IN THIS PRESENTATION, UM, OF THE LAST YEAR OR SO IS A LOT OF ENGAGEMENT.
SO I THINK THAT THERE'S A LOT OF VOICES AND JUST LIKE ANY TOOL THAT WE'RE STARTING WITH THE ONSET, THERE'S ALWAYS THE HOPE THAT IT CAN BE IMPROVED UPON.
UM, IF THERE'S ANY AMENDMENTS THAT THIS BODY WANTS TO MAKE, WE HAVE THE BASE MOTION.
UM, BUT THAT'S WHY I MADE THE MOTION.
UM, ANYBODY SPEAKING AGAINST WE'RE OFFERING AMENDMENT.
SO I DID WANT TO SEE IF, UH, COMMISSIONER ANDERSON WANTED TO ADD HIS AMENDMENT TO THE PLAN, UM, BECAUSE I DO AGREE WITH THE, THAT THAT'S AN IMPORTANT THING TO RECOMMEND THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS.
AND I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO, TO SEE IF WE COULD PUT IN A STRONG RECOMMENDATION FOR AMBASSADORS, THE CONTINUATION OF THE AMBASSADORS, WHICH WOULD SPEAK TO SOME OF THE ISSUES THAT WE'VE HEARD TODAY IN TERMS OF COMMUNICATION AND OUTREACH TO, TO FOLKS.
BUT I WILL DEFER TO COMMISSIONER ANDERSON IF HE WANTS TO PUT HIS INTO A, A, AN AMENDMENT.
BUT I WOULD LIKE TO, UH, HAVE ONE THAT SPEAKS TO THE CONTINUATION OF USING COMMUNITY BASED
[00:40:01]
AMBASSADORS TO DO OUTREACH WITH THE FOR THE PLAN.THANK YOU FOR A SECOND ON THAT.
SECOND BY COMMISSIONER JOHNSON, DID YOU WANNA SPEAK TO THAT ONE ANYMORE? COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS? I'M NOT SURE I CAN
NO, I WON'T MAKE YOU, UH, SPEAK TO THAT TOO MUCH MORE IF YOU DON'T WANT TO.
ANY OTHER SPEAKING FOR OR AGAINST THIS AMENDMENT TO THE MOTION? THIS IS ABOUT, UM, REALLY STRESSING THE IMPORTANCE OF THE COMMUNITY AMBASSADORS AS THE PLAN MOVES FORWARD.
UM, LET'S GO AHEAD AND TAKE A VOTE ON THIS.
UM, ALL OF THOSE IN FAVOR OF THIS AMENDMENT.
UM, ALL RIGHT, THAT IS, UH, NINE WITH COMMISSIONER HAYNES.
AND JUST SO IN CASE I MISSED ANYBODY ANYBODY'S VOTING AGAINST OR ABSTAINING.
THAT ONE, THAT AMENDMENT PASSES.
ANY OTHER AMENDMENTS CHAIR? I LIKE WHERE COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS'S HEAD IS AND, UH, I LOVE THAT COMMISSIONER MAXWELL BROUGHT THAT UP, SO I'M LOOKING TO HER.
I THINK SHE'S GOT ONE OF HER TIME.
I, I WAS GONNA SAY, I'LL JUMP IN.
UM, I'D LOVE TO, UM, SUGGEST THE GENERAL AMENDMENT THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION, UM, EMPHASIZES RECOMMENDED RECOMMENDATION, UM, 81 IN THE PLAN AND URGES CITY COUNCIL TO MOVE QUICKLY TO BEGIN THE, TO EXAMINE FURTHER EXAMINE A TDR PROGRAM FOR THE CITY OF BOSTON.
ALL RIGHT, SECOND BY COMMISSIONER ANDERSON.
DID YOU WANNA SPEAK TO THAT ANYMORE? COMMISSIONER MAXWELL? UH, I THINK WE'VE COVERED IT, BUT I DO THINK IT'S AN IMPORTANT ELEMENT OF THIS PLAN, AND I'M HAPPY AS A PLANNING COMMISSIONER TO REALLY EMPHASIZE THAT WE THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE SOMETHING WE REALLY HELP US AS WE MOVE FORWARD WITH ADDITIONAL ZONING CASES RELATED TO HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
ANYBODY SPEAKING AGAINST OR FOR, I'D LIKE TO SPEAK FOR AND JUST THE FACT THAT WHENEVER I'VE HEARD FROM THE FOLKS WHO STAFF OR NEIGHBORS OR COMMUNITY MEMBERS OR SOMEBODY REALLY WANTED SOMETHING TO BE HISTORIC AGAINST SOMEONE'S WISHES, THE TYPICALLY THE PERSON FIGHTING THAT FOUGHT IT ON THE GROUNDS OF YOU'RE, IT'S JUST REMOVING MY ABILITY TO DO X, Y, AND Z AND THIS OPENS THAT UP.
THIS ACTUALLY CREATES VALUE FOR OUR, OUR HISTORIC PROGRAM IN A WAY WHERE WE'RE REALLY GONNA SEE, I THINK A LOT MORE PEOPLE WANT TO BE A PART OF IT INSTEAD OF TRYING THEIR BEST TO NOT BE A PART OF IT.
SO INSTEAD OF SEEING, YOU KNOW, DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT, HOPEFULLY WE CAN JUST SEE MORE OF THIS AND IT'D BE GREAT TO HAVE THIS PROGRAM UP AND RUNNING ASAP.
ANYBODY ELSE SPEAKING FOR OR AGAINST? YES.
I'M GONNA SPEAK, UH, KIND OF, I GUESS, UM, I, I LIKE THE, UH, IDEA AND, AND, UM, READING KEY TO THE CITY.
SO I'M GETTING HIP ON ALL YOU, UH, ALL THESE TERMS, BUT I ALSO DON'T WANT THIS TO, TO JUMP IN FRONT OF.
I WANT TO, YOU KNOW, WE'VE GOT SO MANY THINGS THAT ARE BACKED UP.
UH, THIS SHOULD NOT TAKE PRIORITY OVER THINGS.
UM, AND, AND ARE ARE GREAT REFORMS AND SHOULD, SHOULD HAVE ALREADY BEEN ON THE BOOKS.
UNLESS THERE'S OTHERS WANTING TO SPEAK, LET'S GO AHEAD AND TAKE A VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT.
RECOMMENDATION 81, UH, MADE BY COMMISSIONER MAXWELL.
SECOND BY COMMISSIONER ANDERSON.
ALL OF THOSE IN FAVOR? 3, 4, 9, 10, 10.
UH, COMMISSIONER BARR RAMIREZ.
ALRIGHT, GOING BACK TO, UM, OTHER AMENDMENTS OR THOSE SPEAKING FOR OR AGAINST THE MAIN MOTION AS AMENDED.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S GO AHEAD AND TAKE A VOTE ON THIS.
THIS DOES INCLUDE TWO AMENDMENTS, ONE ABOUT THE AMBASSADOR PROGRAM, THE OTHER ABOUT THE TDR, UM, AND MOVING FORWARD WITH STAFF'S, UH, RECOMMENDATION.
SO ALL OF THOSE IN FAVOR, 1, 2, 3, 4, 9.
THANK YOU MS. GARZA FOR COMING OUT.
UM, NUMBER TWO, WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE HEARING THAT TONIGHT.
[00:45:01]
OUR BACKUP IF YOU WANT A LITTLE BIT MORE INFORMATION ABOUT THAT.[3. Staff briefing regarding the zoning cases received to date requesting the Density Bonus 90 (DB90) District. Presentation by Eric Thomas, 512-974-7940, eric.thomas@austintexas.gov, Planning Department.]
MOVE ON TO OUR STAFF BRIEFINGS.UM, THE FIRST ONE WILL BE, UH, ABOUT THE DENSITY BONUS OR DB 90 DISTRICT AND, UH, DATA THAT WE CAN, UH, GLEAN FROM THAT TO DATE.
SO MR. ERIC THOMAS, I'LL LET YOU TAKE IT AND YOU'LL HAVE, I THINK WE HAVE 10 MINUTES SLATED FOR STAFF PRESENTATION.
JUST LET ME KNOW IF YOU NEED MORE AND WE CAN SEE HOW THE COMMISSION FEELS ABOUT THAT.
I'M ERIC THOMAS, DIVISION MANAGER WITH THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT, AND I'M HERE TONIGHT TO PROVIDE A BRIEFING ON THE CASES THAT WE'VE RECEIVED TO DATE, WHICH HAVE REQUESTED DENSITY BONUS 90 OR DB 90 ZONING.
I'D LIKE TO BEGIN BY BRIEFLY SUMMARIZING THE HISTORY OF THE DB 90 PROGRAM IN 2022, CITY COUNCIL ADOPTED CHANGES TO THE VERTICAL MIXED USE OR VMU BUILDING PROGRAM, ADDING A SECOND TIER KNOWN AS VM U2, WHICH PROVIDED UP TO 30 FEET ADDITIONAL BUILDING HEIGHT IN EXCHANGE FOR COMMUNITY BENEFITS.
LATER IN 2022, COUNCIL ADOPTED AN ORDINANCE CREATING AN INCENTIVE PROGRAM THAT ALLOWED RESIDENTIAL USES IN COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS REFERRED TO AS RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL.
THIS PROGRAM ALSO REQUIRED INCREASED COMMUNITY BENEFITS IN EXCHANGE FOR THE ADDITIONAL USES.
IN 2023, THE VMU TWO RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL AND COMPATIBILITY ON CORRIDORS ORDINANCES WERE INVALIDATED.
IN FEBRUARY OF THIS YEAR, THE COUNCIL ADOPTED AN ORDINANCE CREATING THE DENSITY BONUS 90 OR DB 90, COMBINING DISTRICT AND DENSITY BONUS PROGRAM, WHICH INCLUDES RE REQUIREMENTS AND INCENTIVES SIMILAR TO VM U2 PROVISIONS.
AS PART OF THE ADOPTION DB 90 CITY COUNCIL ALSO INITIATED THE REZONING OF PROPERTY THAT WAS IMPACTED WHEN THE THREE PREVIOUS ORDINANCES WERE INVALIDATED.
HOWEVER, INITIATION WAS LIMITED TO THE WAIVER OF FEES.
THEN IN AUGUST, CITY COUNCIL ADOPTED AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE DB 90 REQUIREMENTS.
OKAY, IN EXCHANGE FOR THE PROVISION OF INCOME RESTRICTED HOUSING, DB 90 PROVIDES FOR A MIX OF USES 30 FEET OF ADDITIONAL HEIGHT WITH A MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT OF 90 FEET AND EXEMPTIONS FOR MINIMUM LOT AREA MAXIMUM FAR, MAXIMUM BUILDING COVERAGE, CERTAIN SETBACKS AND COMPATIBILITY STANDARDS.
TO DATE, THE CITY HAS RECEIVED 56 APPLICATIONS TO REZONE INTO THE DB 90 COMBINING DISTRICT.
AS I PROCEED, YOU'LL HEAR ME REFER TO THESE CASES AS NEW CASES, CITY INITIATED CASES OR AMENDED CASES.
A NEW CASE REFERS TO AN APPLICATION FOR DB 90 ON A SITE THAT WAS NOT IMPACTED BY THE INVALIDATION OF THE VMU TWO RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL OR COMPATIBILITY ON CORRIDORS ORDINANCES.
A CITY INITIATED CASE REFERS TO A CASE THAT WAS IMPACTED BY THE INVALIDATION OF THE VMU TWO RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL OR COMPATIBILITY ON CORRIDORS ORDINANCES, AND AS SUCH WAS ELIGIBLE FOR A FEE WAIVER.
THESE CASES ARE LOCATED ON PROPERTIES THAT REZONED INTO VMU TWO.
PREVIOUSLY, UM, HAD A SITE PLAN IN REVIEW, RELYING ON RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL OR COMPATIBILITY ON CORRIDORS OR WERE OTHERWISE IMPACTED BY THE INVALIDATION.
AN AMENDED CASE REFERS TO A REZONING CASE THAT WAS SUBMITTED TO REQUEST VM U2 BEFORE THE PROGRAM WAS INVALIDATED AND HAS SINCE BEEN AMENDED TO REQUEST DD 90 INSTEAD OF THE 56 CASES RECEIVED TO DATE.
27 ARE NEW, 24 ARE CITY INITIATED AND FIVE ARE AMENDED.
EIGHT CASES HAVE REQUESTED A MODIFICATION TO THE GROUND FLOOR, PEDESTRIAN ORIENTED COMMERCIAL, AND CIVIC SPACES REQUIREMENT.
SEVEN OF THOSE REQUESTS HAVE ALREADY BEEN TO PLANNING COMMISSION.
OF THE SEVEN STAFF RECOMMENDED GRANTING THE MODIFICATION REQUEST FOR FIVE CASES WHILE THE COMMISSION RECOMMENDED GRANTING EACH OF THEM.
THE AVERAGE AREA PER CASE FOR THE CASES SUBMITTED TO DATE IS FOUR AND ONE THIRD ACRES.
ADDITIONALLY, 16 CASES HAVE BEEN LESS THAN ONE ACRE IN AREA, WHILE FIVE CASES HAVE BEEN 10 ACRES, AN AREA OR LARGER.
OF THE 56 TOTAL CASES, TWO HAVE AB ABUTTED, A SMP, LEVEL FIVE, ROADS SIX HAVE AB BUTTED A SMP LEVEL FOUR ROADS 31 CASES HAVE AB ABUTTED LEVEL THREE ROADS, 11 CASES HAVE ABUTTED.
LEVEL TWO ROADS AND SIX HAVE ABUTTED AS S AND P LEVEL ONE ROADS.
OF THE 56 TOTAL CASES SEVEN HAVE BEEN IN COUNCIL DISTRICT ONE FOUR CASES HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT TWO 15 CASES OR 20% OF THE TOTAL CASES HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT THREE, SEVEN CASES HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT FOUR FIVE.
IN DISTRICT FIVE THERE HAVE BEEN NO CASES SUBMITTED IN DISTRICT SIX THREE IN DISTRICT SEVEN, ONE IN DISTRICT EIGHT 12 CASES, OR 21% IN DISTRICT NINE AND TWO CASES IN DISTRICT 10 OF THE 56,
[00:50:01]
TOTAL CASES 26 ARE CURRENTLY MOVING THROUGH THE REVIEW AND PUBLIC HEARING PROCESS.29 CASES HAVE COMPLETED THE REZONING PROCESS AND ONE CASE HAS BEEN WITHDRAWN.
THE MAP ON THIS SLIDE, AND YOU'LL SEE A FEW ITERATIONS OF THIS MAP, SHOWS THE LOCATION OF EACH DB 90 CASE.
RED CIRCLES INDICATE A CLOSED CASE OR WHICH ONE WHICH HAS BEEN COMPLETED.
BLUE CIRCLES INDICATE CASES WHICH ARE STILL MOVING THROUGH THE PROCESS AND THE GREEN CIRCLE REPRESENTS THE CASE, WHICH WAS WITHDRAWN.
OF THE 27 NEW CASES WHICH HAVE BEEN RECEIVED 19 ARE CURRENTLY IN REVIEW OR OTHERWISE MOVING THROUGH THE PROCESS.
SEVEN HAVE BEEN COMPLETED AND ONE WAS WITHDRAWN.
THREE OF THOSE CASES HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT ONE, TWO IN DISTRICT TWO, SEVEN IN DISTRICT THREE, FOUR IN DISTRICT FOUR, THREE IN DISTRICT FIVE.
THERE HAVE BEEN NO NEW CASES IN DISTRICT SIX, SEVEN, OR EIGHT.
THERE HAVE BEEN SEVEN IN DISTRICT NINE AND ONE IN DISTRICT 10.
AGAIN, THIS MAP SHOWS THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE NEW CASES AROUND THE CITY OF THE 24 CITY INITIATED CASES RECEIVED TO DATE SIX ARE STILL MOVING THROUGH THE PROCESS WHILE 18 HAVE COMPLETED THE REZONING PROCESS.
FOUR OF THOSE HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT ONE, TWO IN DISTRICT TWO, SIX IN DISTRICT THREE, THREE IN DISTRICT FOUR, ONE IN DISTRICT FIVE, NO CASES RECEIVED IN DISTRICT SIX, TWO IN DISTRICT SEVEN, ONE IN DISTRICT EIGHT, FOUR IN DISTRICT NINE, AND ONE IN DISTRICT 10.
THIS MAP SHOWS THE DISTRIBUTION OF CITY INITIATED CASES AROUND THE CITY.
AGAIN, RED CIRCLES INDICATED CLOSED CASE OR ONE WHICH HAS BEEN COMPLETED.
MEANWHILE, THE BLUE CIRCLES INDICATE CASES WHICH ARE STILL MOVING THROUGH THE PROCESS OF THE FIVE AMENDED CASES RECEIVED TO DATE.
ONE CASE IS MOVING THROUGH THE PROCESS AND FOUR HAVE BEEN COMPLETED.
TWO OF THOSE HAVE BEEN IN DISTRICT THREE AND DISTRICTS FIVE, SEVEN, AND NINE HAVE EACH RECEIVED ONE CASE.
HERE'S THE MAP SHOWING THE LOCATION OF EACH AMENDED CASE.
AS A REMINDER, AMENDED CASES ARE THOSE WHICH ORIGINALLY REQUESTED VM U2, BUT EVENTUALLY WERE AMENDED TO REQUEST DB 90.
THIS CHART ILLUSTRATES THE VOLUME OF DB 90 CASES RECEIVED PER MONTH IN 2024 WHILE DB 90 WAS NOT ADOPTED UNTIL LATE FEBRUARY.
THIS CHART INCLUDES A FEW OLDER CASES, WHICH RELIED ON ORDINANCES THAT WERE INVALIDATED AFTER THE APPLICATION WAS SUBMITTED.
SO TWO CASES WERE RECEIVED IN FEBRUARY AFTER THE ADOPTION OF DB 90.
THERE WAS A WAVE OF CASES SUBMITTED WITH 13 IN MARCH, 11 IN APRIL AND SEVEN IN MAY.
ONE CASE WAS RECEIVED IN JUNE, FOLLOWED BY A SPIKE OF SUBMITTALS.
SEVEN IN JULY TWO WERE RECEIVED IN AUGUST 6TH IN SEPTEMBER.
AND ONE CASE HAS BEEN RECEIVED IN OCTOBER, AT LEAST AS OF THE TIME THIS DATA WAS UPDATED LAST WEEK WHEN A REZONING APPLICATION REQUESTING DB 90 IS RECEIVED, CITY STAFF TAKES A COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH TO REVIEWING THE MERITS OF THE CASE.
THE STANDARD FORMAL REVIEW DISCIPLINES INCLUDE TRANSPORTATION AND PUBLIC WORKS, AUSTIN WATER, ENVIRONMENTAL, AUSTIN, FIRE DEPARTMENT, PARKS AND RECREATION SITE PLAN AND COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING.
COMMENTS FROM EACH DISCIPLINE ARE COMPILED AND CONTRIBUTE TO THE STAFF.
RECOMMENDATION STAFF ALSO CONSIDERS A WIDE RANGE OF OF PLANNING PRINCIPLES AND BASES FOR RECOMMENDATION.
FOR EXAMPLE, THE REZONING SHOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH POLICIES AND PRINCIPLES ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OR PLANNING COMMISSION.
ZONING SHOULD PROMOTE CLEARLY IDENTIFIED COMMUNITY GOALS SUCH AS CREATING EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES OR PROVIDING FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
AND THE PROPOSED ZONING DISTRICT, OR EXCUSE ME, THE PROPOSED ZONING SHOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE PURPOSE STATEMENT OF THE DISTRICT SOUGHT FOR EACH REQUEST.
STAFF STUDIES THE PROXIMITY OF THE SITE TO EXISTING AND PLANNED PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS.
THIS INCLUDES THE MODE DIVERSITY AND FREQUENCY, FREQUENCY OF SERVICE.
THE EXISTING ZONING PATTERN IN THE VICINITY OF THE PROPOSED REZONING IS ALSO CONSIDERED INCLUDING THE LOCATION ON THE BLOCK, FOR EXAMPLE, WHETHER IT'S ON A CORNER OR MIDBLOCK.
SIMILARLY, AS A HOLISTIC UNDERSTANDING OF THE POTENTIALLY DYNAMIC LAND USE CONDITIONS IS NECESSARY.
ZONING CASE HISTORY FOR THE SURROUNDING CONTEXT IS REVIEWED.
EXISTING STREET SIDEWALK AND INFRASTRUCTURE CHARACTERISTICS ARE STUDIED FOR THE SITE AND THE CONTEXT AND WHEN NECESSARY OR APPROPRIATE INPUT FROM ADDITIONAL DEPARTMENTS OR AGENCIES MAY BE SOUGHT.
THIS COULD INCLUDE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DATA TRENDS AND RESOURCES, INFORMATION OR COLLABORATION FROM THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT OR INPUT FROM A ISD LONG RANGE PLANNING OR URBAN DESIGN STAFF TYPICALLY DISCUSSES EACH CASE MULTIPLE TIMES IN FULL ZONING TEAM MEETINGS BEFORE SETTLING ON A FORMAL RECOMMENDATION.
AND WITH THAT, THANK YOU AND I'M HAPPY TO TAKE ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MIGHT HAVE.
ALRIGHT, IF YOU WANNA STICK AROUND UP HERE, WE'LL OPEN IT UP FOR QUESTIONS.
[00:55:01]
THE FIRST ONE? COMMISSIONER COX, WHY DON'T YOU JUMP IN? I KNOW THIS IS ONE THAT YOU'VE BEEN WAITING FOR FOR A WHILE.WELL, AND THAT'S WHY I'M STILL HERE.
I ACTUALLY HAVE ANOTHER CALL I HAVE TO GET ON AT SIX, SO I LITERALLY HAVE TWO MINUTES.
BUT, UH, IT, THE PRESENTATION ENDED WITH TWO MINUTES TO SPARE.
SO I GUESS MY QUESTION, UM, I, I'VE GOT A COUPLE, UH, I I THOUGHT IT WAS INTERESTING THE, UH, THE, THE A SMP CLASSIFICATIONS OF THE DB 90 CASES AND HOW, IF I, IF I UNDERSTOOD CORRECTLY, THE MAJORITY OF THESE ARE ON A SMP LEVEL, ONE, TWO, AND THREE STREETS, IS THAT CORRECT? YES, COMMISSIONER.
IS THERE A REASON WHY THESE CASES ARE POPPING UP? MOSTLY ON OUR SMALLER KIND OF NEIGHBORHOOD SCALE STREETS, AND I GUESS MY CONCERN IS THAT THEY'RE POPPING UP INTERNAL TO WHAT IS OFTEN AN SF LARGELY SF ZONE NEIGHBORHOOD, RATHER THAN BEING CLOSER TO OUR, OUR LARGER STREETS THAT TEND TO HAVE MORE NOT ONLY VEHICLE CAPACITY, BUT ALSO MORE TRANSIT CAPACITY AS TO WHY THOSE LOCATIONS HAVE BEEN MORE POPULAR WITH APPLICANTS.
I WOULDN'T HAVE A GREAT ANSWER PROBABLY.
UM, BUT AS PLANNERS, WE ARE HOPING TO SEE A, A LARGE PERCENTAGE OF THEM ALONG, OR AT LEAST IN VERY CLOSE PROXIMITY TO PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
UM, ARE YOU ABLE, I KNOW WE, THIS WAS PASSED A DECENT TIME AGO, BUT ARE YOU AWARE OF LIKE ANY POTENTIAL DRAWBACKS OR ISSUES WITH, WITH DB 90 BEING 90 VERSUS HAVING A DB 60 OR A DB 75 FOR STAFF TO KIND OF PULL FROM, RATHER THAN BEING STUCK WITH THAT 90 FOOT HEIGHT FOR ALL OF THESE CASES? ESPECIALLY, ESPECIALLY SINCE COMPATIBILITY IS WAIVED, UH, IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE MAY BE, UM, A RESOLUTION IN THE NEAR FUTURE THAT WOULD ADDRESS THAT AND WOULD PROVIDE ADDITIONAL OPTIONS FOR US TO RECOMMEND A LOWER HEIGHT FOR DB 90.
SO, SO I DO UNDERSTAND THE, THE QUESTION IS 90 FEET APPROPRIATE EVERYWHERE AND STAFF HAS RECOMMENDED ALTERNATE ZONING DISTRICTS ON A COUPLE CASES.
AND SO THOSE WOULD BE EXAMPLES OF, OF WHERE WE DIDN'T NECESSARILY AGREE THAT 90 FEET WAS APPROPRIATE.
SO YES, I, I WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.
YEAH, AND I, I KIND OF, AT, AT LEAST IN MY EXPERIENCE, THAT SEEMS TO BE THE MAJORITY OF THE PUSHBACK WITH THE PUBLIC ON DB 90 CASES.
WOULD YOU TEND TO AGREE OR DO YOU THINK THAT THERE'S KIND OF SOME OVERRIDING TOPICS ON THE PUBLIC, UH, UH, THE PUBLIC OPPOSITION TO THESE DB 90 CASES? EACH CASE IS CERTAINLY UNIQUE AND THERE ARE LOTS OF OVERLAPPING COMPLEXITIES AND INTERESTS, BUT I, I WOULD SAY YES, THAT THE HEIGHT IS, IS USUALLY THE MAIN STICKING POINT WHEN THERE'S OPPOSITION TO A CASE.
I'M A FEW MINUTES LATE TO MY OTHER CALL, SO I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME,
OTHER QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER ANDERSON.
SO THANKS FOR ALL THE, THE NUMBERS AND THE, THE, UH, LOOKS LIKE YOU GUYS REALLY DUG DEEP INTO THIS.
DO YOU HAVE A TOTAL SQUARE FOOT OR A TOTAL ACREAGE THAT HAS BEEN REZONED DB 90? I FEEL LIKE, UH, THERE WAS A LITTLE BIT OF A, FOR A MINUTE THERE, LIKE A SKY IS FALLING TYPE SENTIMENT AMONGST A COUPLE OF FOLKS.
WE OFTEN HEAR FROM WHO, UH, ARE MOTIVATED TO SHOW UP TO STOP THE DEVELOPMENT OF HOUSING QUITE OFTENTIMES.
AND SO I'M JUST CURIOUS IF WE HAVE REAL NUMBERS TO SHOW THAT IT'S NOT A HUGE PERCENTAGE, BUT RATHER IT'S PROBABLY STILL MUCH LESS THAN 1% OF AUSTIN.
I DO HAVE THE NUMBER AND I APOLOGIZE.
I MEANT TO PUT THAT IN MY REMARKS.
IF YOU JUST GIVE ME A MINUTE, I SHOULD BE ABLE TO LOCATE THAT.
UM, I'M, I'M GLAD THIS BODY GETS, COUNCIL DID AMAZING THINGS TRYING TO MAKE THIS BY RIGHT, AND IT'S TOO BAD WE DIDN'T GET THERE, BUT IT IS GOOD THAT STAFF IS BRINGING THESE FORWARD AND THAT FOLKS ARE LOOKING TO BUILD THIS.
UM, I KNOW THERE WAS A PREVIOUS QUESTION, AND AS SOON AS YOU HAVE THE ANSWER, FEEL FREE TO SPEAK UP.
125 ACRES, 125 ACRES, AND REMIND ME HOW MANY ACRES THE CITY OF AUSTIN IS NOW THAT NUMBER.
SO WE'RE TALKING MUCH LESS, MUCH, MUCH, MUCH LESS THAN 1% OF AUSTIN.
SO IT TURNS OUT THE SKY'S NOT FALLING.
AND, UH, AS FAR AS I KNOW, THERE WERE SOME QUESTIONS THAT I'M GONNA AGO ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT, UM, WHY AREN'T WE JUST SEEING THESE ON LARGE CORRIDORS? I MEAN, I DON'T KNOW ABOUT Y'ALL, BUT I'VE LIVED ON BIG ROADS
[01:00:01]
AND I'VE LIVED ON SMALL ROADS, AND THE IDEA OF LIVING ON A TWO LANE ROAD IS SO MUCH MORE APPEALING THAN A FOUR OR FIVE LANE ROAD.SO I, I APPRECIATE STAFF GIVING RECOMMENDATION TO THESE DEVELOPMENTS THAT ARE GONNA GO UP IN AREAS THAT ARE LESS ABOUT THE AUTOMOBILE AND MORE ABOUT PEOPLE GETTING AROUND ON IN OTHER FORMS AND KIND OF MORE QUAINT, CHARMING, SAFE AREAS.
OTHER QUESTIONS? GOING ONCE, GOING TWICE.
COMMISSIONER HAYNES, I SEE THAT YOU CAME ON SCREEN.
I WAS, UH, ADMITTEDLY TRYING TO DO A LITTLE BIT OF MULTITASKING.
TELL ME, O OF THE, UH, PROPOSALS THAT Y'ALL RECEIVED, HOW MANY HAVE, UH, A YOU TURNED DOWN OR, OR DECIDED NOT TO GO FORWARD? STAFF RECOMMEND NOT TO GO FORWARD AND, AND B UH, THE APPLICANT DECIDED TO WITHDRAW.
SO FAR THERE HAVE BEEN TWO CASES WHERE STAFF HAS RECOMMENDED NOT GRANTING DB 90, UM, AND ONE CASE HAS BEEN WITHDRAWN BY AN APPLICANT.
AND THE TOTAL NUMBER OF CASES? 56.
WELL, BUT THAT DOES NOT MEAN 56 INCLUDES CASES THAT ARE IN REVIEW.
SO THERE MIGHT BE SOME IN THERE THAT WE WON'T RECOMMEND TB 90.
AND THEN OF THOSE CASES THAT STAFF RECOMMENDED NOT GOING FORWARD, WHAT WAS, UM, UH, DID THE PLANNING COMMISSION, UH, OVERRIDE Y'ALL? YES.
PLANNING COMMISSION DID, UH, RECOMMEND DB 90 ZONING.
SO, SO THERE'S ONE CASE THAT'S BEEN WITHDRAWN OUT OF 56 CORRECT.
UM, SO IT SEEMS LIKE THE MARKET IS SPEAKING TO US THAT, UM, THAT OVERWHELMINGLY DB 90 IS A, UH, PRETTY POPULAR PROGRAM.
IS THAT TRUE
IS THAT TRUE? WE'VE CERTAINLY RECEIVED QUITE A FEW CASES, SO IT, IT SEEMS PRETTY POPULAR.
YOU KNOW, IF YOU TAKE INTO ACCOUNT OTHER OPTIONS WE HAVE FOR REZONINGS, DB 90 IS DEFINITELY PRETTY POPULAR RIGHT NOW, BUT THAT WOULD BE TO BE EXPECTED WITH THE NUMBER OF CASES THAT WERE IMPACTED BY THE INVALIDATION OF THE PREVIOUS THREE ORDINANCES.
SO THAT, UM, AS A, AS I, I DON'T KNOW YOUR BACKGROUND, UH, AS AN ECONOMIST THEN, THEN I GUESS THE WAY I WOULD LOOK AT THAT IS WE MIGHT BE OUT OF, UM, OUT OF, UH, THE REALM OF MANAGING, UH, SUPPLY AND DEMAND THAT MAYBE WE'RE, WE'RE NOT OFFERING AS MUCH, UM, DEMAND AS WE HAVE SUPPLY BECAUSE, UH, PEOPLE ARE, ARE ACCESSING THIS AND, AND, AND, AND USING MORE THAN WE'RE ABLE TO DO.
AND SO THAT MAYBE WE NEED TO ADJUST OUR, UH, SUPPLY AND DEMAND MODEL HERE, UM, AND LOOK AT THE INCENTIVES TO MAKE SURE THAT WE, UH, WE ARE ACTUALLY NOT JUST GIVING AWAY THE FARM AND, UM, UH, TRY TO ADJUST THOSE SO THAT, UM, THAT WE, THAT WE BETTER BALANCE, SUPPLY AND DEMAND WHEN IT COMES TO OFFERING INCENTIVES FOR, UH, PROMOTING MILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF, OF INCOME AND MILLIONS OF DOLLARS INCENTIVES WHILE GETTING VERY LITTLE IN RETURN.
BUT, UH, THAT'S NOT A QUESTION, SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO ANSWER THAT.
THAT'S ALL I HAVE, MADAM CHAIR.
COMMISSIONER HAYNES, OTHER QUESTIONS? YES, COMMISSIONER JOHNSON AND COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS.
UM, I'M JUST CURIOUS, HOW MANY, DO YOU KNOW ROUGHLY THE NUMBER OF REZONING OR ZONING CASES, UH, THE CITY HAS RECEIVED SO FAR THIS YEAR IN TOTAL? JUST, JUST INCLUDING DB 90, YOUR TOTAL NUMBER OF ZONING APPLICATIONS.
I DON'T HAVE THE EXACT NUMBER IN FRONT OF ME.
THAT'S SOMETHING ELSE THAT I COULD PULL UP IF SURE.
BUT WE ARE SOMEWHERE AROUND 150.
SO ABOUT A THIRD OF THE ALL ZONING CASES HAVE BEEN DB 90? THAT'S CORRECT.
UM, AND JUST AS A POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE, THE CITY OF AUSTIN IS ABOUT 205,000 ACRES, SO THAT'S 0.06% OF THE CITY IS NOW, UH, DB 90.
UM, HAVE YOU, IN REVIEWING THESE CASES, HAVE YOU HEARD, UH, MORE OR LESS OR ABOUT THE SAME AMOUNT OF PUBLIC INPUT ON DB 90 CASES AS YOU HAVE OTHER REZONINGS? ARE THEY NOTABLY,
[01:05:01]
UH, HIGHER VOLUME OF COMMENTS THAT YOU RECEIVE FROM MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, SMALLER, ABOUT THE SAME? NO IDEA.THIS, MY RESPONSE WILL BE BASED OFF OF NOT NUMBERS THAT I HAVE SURE.
PULLED UP IN FRONT OF ME RIGHT NOW.
UM, IT, I WOULD SAY YES, THERE'S MORE PUBLIC INPUT.
PROBABLY MORE COMMENT CARDS RECEIVED THAN JUST A STANDARD REZONING CASE.
BUT THAT BEING SAID, IT, IT REALLY DOES DEPEND ON THE CASE.
UM, SOME DB 90 CASES, WE WON'T GET ANY OR, OR HARDLY ANY, UM, PUBLIC COMMENT.
BUT THEN OTHER CASES WE MIGHT RECEIVE DOZENS OF EMAILS, PHONE CALLS, COMMENT CARDS, UH, BUT IF, IF I HAD TO GIVE AN ANSWER ON WHETHER IT'S MORE OR LESS, I, I WOULD SAY THAT IT IS, IT'S MORE OKAY THAN A A TYPICAL CASE.
AND, UM, HAVE YOU NOTICED A REDUCTION IN APPLICATIONS FOR ANY OTHER SPECIFIC TYPES OF ZONING COMPARED TO PAST YEARS SINCE DB 90 WAS CREATED? UH, MF DISTRICTS OR, YOU KNOW, ANYTHING ELSE? YES, DEFINITELY.
SO AGAIN, I DON'T HAVE THAT DATA SPECIFICALLY PULLED UP.
UM, BUT WE'RE OBVIOUSLY SEEING MORE DB 90, WE'RE NOT SEEING AS MUCH JUST C-S-M-U-V MM-HMM.
SO IT WOULD BE FAIR TO SAY THAT APPLICANTS ARE GENERALLY CHOOSING MORE TO OPT INTO THE BONUS PROGRAM AND PROVIDE SOME AFFORDABLE HOUSING AS OPPOSED TO ZONING DISTRICTS THAT ALLOW THEM TO DEVELOP SIMILAR PROJECTS WITHOUT AFFORDABLE HOUSING? YES.
AND THAT WOULD ALSO WAY FACTOR INTO STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION AS WELL.
SO I WAS TRYING TO LOOK AT THE MAPS AND DETERMINE ARE THE, UM, MAJORITY OF THESE DB 90 CASES CONCENTRATED IN EAST AUSTIN? YES, I WOULD.
I WOULD SAY THE MAJORITY ARE CONCENTRATED, UM, EAST AUSTIN AS WELL AS, UH, SOUTH CENTRAL AND THE PUSHBACK, UM, HAVE YOU RECEIVED LIKE, PUSHBACK FROM THOSE NEIGHBORHOODS IN EAST AUSTIN? I'D BE, UM, CURIOUS ABOUT WHAT KIND OF PUSHBACK BACK YOU'RE GETTING.
UM, AND IT, IT'S A LOT OF THE SAME PUSHBACK THAT WOULD BE RECEIVED FOR ANY REZONING THAT'S INCREASING ENTITLEMENTS.
UH, BUT A A LOT OF IT, LIKE WE MENTIONED BEFORE, WOULD BE ABOUT HEIGHT, UM, SCALE COMPATIBILITY, THOSE SORTS OF SITE DEVELOPMENT AND, AND BULK AND MASS ASPECTS.
UM, AND OF COURSE WE ALSO DO OCCASIONALLY OR MORE THAN OCCASIONALLY, UH, RECEIVE PUBLIC INPUT THAT IS MORE RELATED TO DISPLACEMENT OR GENTRIFICATION.
AND I, I HAVE ALSO HEARD THAT, SO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT UP.
ANOTHER THING THAT I'VE HEARD THAT PERHAPS YOU CAN SPEAK ABOUT IS THAT THE DB 90, UH, ZONING DOES DISPLACED NEIGHBORHOOD PLANS.
I I WOULD NOT, THAT DOES NOT SOUND ACCURATE TO ME.
SO THE NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN CONTROLS OVER DB 90 IN THE HIERARCHY.
SO, UM, I'M NOT AWARE OF ANY ADMINISTRATIVE OR OR REZONING PROCESS THAT WE'VE SEEN THIS YEAR THAT WOULD, UM, TAKE A CASE OUT OF A NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN.
I GUESS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WAS BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION IN THAT REGARD IS THAT, UM, WHEN UNDER LIKE THE VMU PROGRAM, UM, BECAUSE OF THE SCALE AND THE HEIGHT AND THAT SORT OF THING, UM, IT WOULD FIT MORE IN WITH, WITH, UM, WHERE ALONG THE CORRIDORS THAT WERE MARKED FOR THAT.
AND YET, AND I HOPE I'M MAKING SENSE STILL,
UH, I HEARD THIS FROM THE MONIS NEIGHBORHOOD IN PARTICULAR.
UH, THEY DON'T RESPECT THE, THE NEIGHBORHOOD PLANS IN TERMS OF THE CORRIDORS, WHICH WOULD, WOULD BE THE HIGHER TRANSIT CORRIDORS WHERE THESE, UH, WHERE THERE BE MU TWO CASES WOULD, UH, HAVE ZONING WOULD'VE BEEN ANY TRUTH TO THAT? WELL, A RESPONSE WOULD BE THAT FOR CASES THAT NEED A, A PLUMB OR FUTURE LAND USE MAP CHANGE THERE, THERE WILL STILL BE A NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN AMENDMENT CASE THAT'S RELATED TO THE REZONING.
AND SO OUR LONG RANGE PLANNING TEAM ALSO REVIEWS THOSE CASES HOLISTICALLY AND, UM, HAS AT LEAST ONE NEIGHBORHOOD OR COMMUNITY MEETING, UM, WHERE THAT CASE IS DISCUSSED.
SO WE DO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION THE PROXIMITY TO A CORRIDOR OR TRANSIT, UH, BUT
[01:10:01]
IT IS NOT LIKE, LIKE YOU MENTIONED, IT'S NOT LIMITED TO SITES THAT DIRECTLY ABUT A CORRIDOR.UH, WE DO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION, BUT IT'S, IT'S NOT A REQUIREMENT FOR THESE CASES.
AND MY LAST QUESTION, IF I STILL HAVE TIME, IS WHAT THEN COULD YOU TEASE OUT THE PUSHBACK THAT YOU'RE GETTING ABOUT DISPLACEMENT AND GENTRIFICATION? I WOULD SAY IT'S, IT'S USUALLY A, A, A BROAD POINT ABOUT DISPLACEMENT AND GENTRIFICATION EAST OF I 35 GENERALLY, AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE ARE VERY SENSITIVE TO.
UM, AT THE SAME TIME, DB 90 REQUIRES INCOME RESTRICTIVE UNITS.
AND SO WHILE DENYING DB 90 DOES NOT GUARANTEE THE PRESERVATION OF WHATEVER HAS BEEN DEVELOPED ON THAT SITE TO BEGIN WITH, UM, ADDITIONALLY, IF THE CONTEXT IS RAPIDLY GENTRIFYING OR GENTRIFYING AT ALL, WE COULD AT LEAST HOPE THAT THE INCOME RESTRICTED UNITS MIGHT BE AFFORDABLE TO SOMEONE WHO OTHERWISE WOULD BE DISPLACED BY WHAT ELSE IS GOING ON IN THAT AREA OF TOWN.
SO, UH, WE TOTALLY UNDERSTAND THAT, THAT POINT.
UH, BUT WE, WE HAVE OUR, OUR OPTIONS THAT WE'RE WORKING WITH AND WE JUST TRY TO DO THE BEST WE CAN WITH THOSE.
TO YOUR KNOWLEDGE, ARE ANY OF THE, THE CASES THAT HAVE COME BEFORE, UM, DO THEY, DO THEY RESULT IN A, A LOSS OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING? THAT IS A QUESTION, AN ANSWER I'D HAVE TO GET BACK TO YOU WITH SPECIFICALLY.
UH, THERE, THERE HAVE CERTAINLY BEEN AT LEAST A FEW CASES WHERE THERE IS AN EXISTING MULTIFAMILY STRUCTURE, UM, WHEREAS THERE SOMETIMES WE DON'T KNOW EXACTLY HOW MANY UNITS WILL BE PROVIDED UNTIL A SITE PLAN IS SUBMITTED, FOR EXAMPLE.
SO KNOWING EXACTLY HOW MANY UNITS WILL BE LOST OR REPLACED, SOMETIMES WE DON'T HAVE THAT INFORMATION.
UM, BUT IT'S CERTAINLY SOMETHING THAT WE CONSIDER.
AND I WOULD LIKE YOU TO GET BACK TO ME ON THAT.
UM, WE HAVE THREE MORE SPOTS FOR QUESTIONS.
COMMISSIONER SKIDMORE, FOLLOW UP QUESTION AROUND AFFORDABLE UNITS OF, AND I REALIZE THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THESE CASES OR ZONING CASES YET, AND NOT SITE PLANS, BUT HAS HAVE, UH, PLANNING STAFF PERFORMED PREPARED AN ESTIMATE OF APPROXIMATELY HOW MANY AFFORDABLE UNITS OF COULD BE GENERATED BY THESE CASES? OR HAVE YEAH, THAT'S THE QUESTION.
DO YOU, JUST TO, TO CLARIFY, DO YOU MEAN THE ACTUAL CASES THAT WE HAVE RECEIVED, THE, THE LITERAL REZONING CASES THAT WE HAVE? OR DO YOU JUST MEAN, UH, GENERAL? WELL, NO, I MEAN, I, I THINK I'M, I'M ACTUALLY KIND OF CURIOUS ABOUT THE, THE ZONING CASES WE HAVE, RIGHT? THE PRESENTATION TALKED ABOUT 56 CASES IN TOTAL, 26 WE'RE IN PROCESS, 29 WERE CLOSED OF, WE TALKED ABOUT HOW MUCH LAND, WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THE CITY OF AUSTIN IT WAS.
AND IT'S A NUMBER THAT'S SMALLER THAN ONE 10TH OF 1%, I BELIEVE.
AND I'M KIND OF FOR CONTEXT, I'M CURIOUS TO SEE ABOUT HOW MANY AFFORDABLE UNITS OF ARE WE EXPECTING TO GET FROM THESE? AND I KNOW THAT'S AN ESTIMATE, BUT IT'S, UH, ONE THAT I'M KIND OF INTERESTED IN.
WE DO NOT HAVE THAT ESTIMATE AT THIS TIME WITH SOME CASES IN A SUMMARY LETTER, UH, WE MAY RECEIVE WHAT THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO DO OR WHAT THEY ANTICIPATE DOING.
SOMETIMES WE DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT IT, BUT, BUT YOU ARE RIGHT.
I MEAN, SOMEBODY COULD LOOK AT A SITE, LOOK AT HOW BIG IT IS, IF, IF IT'S ENCUMBERED BY EASEMENTS OR, OR WHAT, WHAT SORTS OF OTHER ASPECTS MIGHT LIMIT DEVELOPMENT, AND YOU COULD COME UP WITH A BROAD IDEA.
UM, I, I DID, I DID ASK DSD, UM, STAFF IF WE HAVE A NUMBER OF UNITS THAT HAVE BEEN SUBMITTED FOR SITE PLANS, AND WE DON'T HAVE THAT DATA YET EITHER.
BUT I THINK MOVING FORWARD, THAT, THAT WOULD BE INTERESTING IF, IF WE HAVE THE RESOURCES.
I, I THINK IT WOULD BE INTERESTING BECAUSE A LOT OF THE DISCUSSION, YOU KNOW, CONCERNED AROUND THESE CASES IS, YOU KNOW, THE, THE CHANGES THAT ARE OCCURRING, UH, TO THESE EXISTING PROPERTIES AND, AND HOW IT MIGHT IMPACT EXISTING COMMUNITIES.
AND I KNOW IT'LL BE SOME TIME BEFORE WE SEE THESE AFFORDABLE UNITS, BUT I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOT LOSE, TO LOSE SENSE OR FOCUS THAT THESE PROPERTIES WILL PRODUCE A QUANTITY OF AFFORDABLE UNITS, AT LEAST TO MY SENSE, THAT IS OF SIGNIFICANTLY LARGE, SIGNIFICANTLY LARGER THAN WE'VE BEEN PRODUCING WITH OTHER TOOLS WE'VE HAD AS A CITY.
OTHER QUESTIONS? ALL RIGHT, IT LOOKS LIKE WE'RE OUT OF OUR QUESTIONS.
[01:15:01]
SO THANK YOU MR. THOMAS FOR YOUR PRESENTATION.AND I KNOW COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS WILL BE LOOKING FOR THAT FOLLOW UP ON THE QUESTION THAT SHE HAD.
[4. Staff briefing regarding demographic trends and population growth in Austin. Presentation by Lila Valencia, 512-978-1559, lila.valencia@austintexas.gov, Planning Department. ]
NUMBER FOUR.THIS IS THE STAFF BRIEFING REGARDING DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS AND POPULATION GROWTH IN AUSTIN BY MS. VALENCIA.
AND YOU'LL HAVE ABOUT 10 MINUTES.
IF YOU NEED MORE, JUST LET US KNOW AND WE'LL TAKE A VOTE ON THAT.
OH, I THINK THERE DEFINITELY WILL BE MORE.
SO BEFORE YOU GET STARTED, I THINK, UH, MS. HARDEN DID MENTION THAT, UM, UNLESS THERE IS OBJECTION, YOU, YOU NEED 20.
UM, ANY OBJECTION, TWO 20 MINUTES,
I'M THE DEMOGRAPHER AT THE CITY OF AUSTIN.
AND THANK YOU FOR, UM, GIVING ME THE OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE THIS INFORMATION WITH YOU.
I KNOW OUR OUR TIME TOGETHER IS SHORT, SO I'M GONNA START BY SUMMARIZING JUST SOME TOP LEVEL FINDINGS THAT KIND OF PROVIDE SOME, SOME CONTEXT.
UM, SO I'LL START JUST WITH, YOU KNOW, JUST SOME, SOME TOP LEVEL FINDINGS THAT USUALLY I, YOU KNOW, KIND OF SHARE IN, IN MULTIPLE SLIDES.
BUT WE KNOW THAT AUSTIN IS THE 11TH LARGEST CITY IN THE COUNTRY.
IT IS PART OF THE SECOND FASTEST GROWING REGION IN THE COUNTRY, THE AUSTIN METRO AREA.
UM, BOTH OF THESE HAVE SOMEWHAT SLOWED, UH, THEIR PACE IN GROWTH.
SO AUSTIN HAS DROPPED FROM THE TOP 10 LARGEST CITY LIST TO NUMBER 11 LAST YEAR.
THE AUSTIN METRO AREA, UM, HAS ALSO SLOWED IN GROWTH AND DROPPED FROM THE FIRST, UH, FASTEST GROWING, UH, REGION IN THE COUNTRY FOR 12 CONSECUTIVE YEARS TO NOW THE SECOND FASTEST GROWING REGION IN THE COUNTRY.
MUCH OF THE SLOWER GROWTH CAN BE DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTED TO THE SLOWING PACE OF THE GROWTH IN AUSTIN.
SO AUSTIN HAS TYPICALLY, UM, DOUBLED ITS POPULATION EVERY 20 TO 25 YEARS.
UM, SO THAT GIVES US AN ANNUAL GROWTH RATE OF ABOUT 2% EVERY YEAR.
TO GIVE YOU A SENSE OF WHERE WE ARE NOW SINCE 2020, AUSTIN STILL, UH, AS OF 2023, HAS NOT YET REACHED THAT 2% GROWTH RATE.
SO, SO GROWTH IS DEFINITELY A LITTLE BIT, UM, SLOWER, BUT AUSTIN CONTINUES TO GROW AND SO DOES THE REGION.
HOWEVER, AUSTIN IS MAKING UP AN EVEN SMALLER SHARE OF THE TOTAL REGION DUE TO ITS OWN SLOWER GROWTH, BUT ALSO DUE TO THE RELATIVELY SIGNIFICANT IN RAPID GROWTH IN THE SUBURBAN AREAS OF THE REGION.
AND OF COURSE, WE CAN'T TALK ABOUT GROWTH IN AUSTIN WITHOUT TALKING ABOUT MIGRATION, SPECIFICALLY DOMESTIC MIGRATION, WHICH IS MIGRATION FROM OTHER PARTS OF THE COUNTRY, BUT ALSO MIGRATION DIRECTLY, UH, FROM OTHER PARTS OF TEXAS.
UM, THIS MAKES UP THE MAIN TYPE OF GROWTH THAT AUSTIN IS EXPERIENCING.
AND THIS TYPE OF GROWTH IS THE KIND OF GROWTH THAT REALLY PLACES IMMEDIATE PRESSURES ON INFRASTRUCTURE AND RESOURCES AND REQUIRES A NIMBLE RESPONSE IN ORDER TO MEET THE NEEDS OF RESIDENTS.
AND THEN ALSO, WE REALLY CAN'T TALK ABOUT MIGRATION WITHOUT TALKING ABOUT THE ECONOMY.
THAT'S REALLY WHAT DRIVES A LOT OF PEOPLE TO THE AUSTIN AREA.
AND AUSTIN HAS LONG BEEN A LEADER IN JOB GROWTH, UH, RELATIVE TO OTHER METROS, BUT MUCH LIKE ITS RECENT POPULATION, UM, SLOW DOWN IN GROWTH, GROWTH, JOB GROWTH HAS ALSO SLOWED DOWN.
AND ALTHOUGH THE MAJORITY OF JOBS ARE STILL WITHIN THE AUSTIN CITY LIMITS, UH, WE STILL, WE CONTINUE TO SEE A DISPERSION OF, UM, JOBS THROUGHOUT THE LARGER REGION.
AND NOW WE HAVE SMALLER SHARES OF POPULATION THAT BOTH LIVE AND WORK IN AUSTIN.
I'M GONNA SHARE, UH, A MAP VERY QUICKLY WITH YOU.
I'M GONNA SHARE A MAP THAT LOOKS AT THE, AT THE GROWTH IN THE METRO REGION.
SO THE AREAS THAT ARE IN DARKEST BLUE ARE THE AREAS THAT REPRESENT THE AREAS OF GREATEST POPULATION GROWTH BETWEEN 2010 AND 2020.
AND THEN ALL OF THOSE AREAS IN, IN RED OR PINK ARE AREAS THAT EXPERIENCE POPULATION DECLINE, AND WE CAN REALLY SEE A LOT OF THAT SUBURBAN GROWTH, RIGHT? ESPECIALLY ALONG THE BORDERS BETWEEN TRAVIS COUNTY AND WILLIAMSON, TRAVIS AND HAYES, AND THEN MANY PARTS OF EASTERN TRAVIS COUNTY.
WHAT WE ALSO SEE THOUGH, WHEN WE REALLY, UM, ZOOM INTO THE CITY CENTER, WHICH IS IN THE INSET, UH, MAP, WE CAN SEE THAT EVEN THOUGH WE SAW A LOT OF GROWTH IN THE SUBURBAN AREAS IN THOSE AREAS WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS, WHERE THE CITY REALLY INTENTIONALLY ENCOURAGED DENSE GROWTH, WE ALSO SAW SIMILAR MAGNITUDE GROWTH IN POPULATION.
[01:20:02]
THIS MAP, UM, LOOKS AT HOUSING UNIT CHANGE, POPULATION GROWTH AND HOUSING UNIT GROWTH ARE VERY HIGHLY CORRELATED.AND SO YOU CAN SEE SIMILAR PATTERNS OF AREAS WHERE WE ADDED THE MOST UNITS BETWEEN 2010 AND 2020.
AGAIN, THOSE AREAS WITHIN THE CITY CENTER WHERE WE ENCOURAGED MORE GROWTH, WE ALSO SAW GROWTH IN POPULATION.
ONE OF THE PATTERNS OF GROWTH THAT WE, UM, LOOKED AT WAS THAT ALL OF THOSE AREAS THAT ARE IN THE OUTLYING PARTS OF THE CITY, SO THE AREAS AROUND LAKELINE AND TECH RIDGE, UM, DOWN IN SOUTHEAST AUSTIN AS WELL AS SOUTHWEST AUSTIN, THOSE AREAS SAW GROWTH IN UNITS, GROWTH IN POPULATION, THAT THAT ALSO RESULTED IN GREATER DIVERSITY.
WHEN WE LOOK AT AREAS THAT ARE CLOSER TO THE CITY CORE, CLOSER TO THE CITY CENTER AREAS LIKE RIVERSIDE AND HOLLY MUELLER AND THE DOWNTOWN AREAS, THOSE ALSO SAW A LOT OF POPULATION GROWTH.
BUT THE POPULATION GROWTH HERE WAS DRIVEN BY THE WHITE POPULATION, AND WE ACTUALLY SAW DECLINES IN MANY SHARES OF POPULATIONS OF COLOR.
AND THEN THERE WAS A COUPLE OF EXCEPTIONS WHERE WE DID SEE SORT OF GROWTH, BUT ALSO THESE AREAS ARE CLOSER TO, UH, THE CENTER CORRIDORS AND IMAGINE AUSTIN CENTERS, AND THOSE INCLUDED THE DOMAIN AND WEST CAMPUS.
THESE SAW BOTH GROWTH, BUT ALSO DIVERSIFICATION.
AND NOW I'M GONNA SHARE WITH YOU A COUPLE OF SLIDES ON, UM, AUSTIN'S DUALITIES, RIGHT? SO WHEN WE'VE LIVED HERE FOR A LITTLE WHILE, WE START TO NOTICE THAT THERE'S A COUPLE OF AUSTIN'S, YOU KNOW, THE AUSTIN STORY THAT WE SHARE A ABOUT, UM, POPULATION GROWTH AND, AND JOB GROWTH.
BUT THERE'S ALSO, UH, A CONCURRENT PATTERN OF GROWING PAINS THAT DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES ARE EXPERIENCING AND BEING IMPACTED IN DIFFERENT WAYS.
SO SOME OF THESE DUALITIES YOU CAN SEE HERE, FOR INSTANCE, AUSTIN AGAIN HAS BEEN GROWING, BUT THAT POPULATION GROWTH IS SLOWING DOWN.
MORE RECENTLY, HOWEVER, AS THIS POPULATION HAS GROWN, WE HAVE SEEN A FARTHER EASTWARD MOVEMENT, PARTICULARLY OF FAMILIES OF COLOR TO AREAS FARTHER AWAY FROM THE CITY CENTER, UH, WITH FEWER RESOURCES AND, UH, GREATER OPPORTUNITY COSTS.
AUSTIN HAS ALSO, UH, GROWN IN TERMS OF HOUSING UNITS.
IN FACT, WE'VE ADDED AN UNPRECEDENTED NUMBER OF UNITS.
AND THROUGH 2023, WE ARE ON PACE TO SURPASS THE NUMBER OF UNITS THAT WE ADDED LAST DECADE.
HOWEVER, HOUSING UNIT GROWTH IN AUSTIN IS NOT KEEPING PACE WITH HOUSEHOLD FORMATION.
AND AS WE LOOK AT INCREASING HOME PRICES IN THE, IN THE REGION, EVEN AS THEY START TO STABILIZE, WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS THAT HOME OWNERSHIP HAS BEEN STAGNATING AS WELL.
AND THEN WITH THE GROWTH IN THE POPULATION OF AUSTIN, WE ALSO SAW, UH, INCREASED DIVERSITY IN ALL AND GROWTH IN ALL RACE AND ETHNICITY GROUPS.
HOWEVER, THIS INCREASED DIVERSITY, UM, REALLY OBSCURES UNIQUE DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFTS THAT ARE TAKING PLACE IN AUSTIN THAT INCLUDE A DECLINING SHARE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN AND HISPANIC POPULATION, AS WELL AS A, A REAL POPULATION DECLINE AMONG, UM, BLACK AND LATINO CHILDREN.
AND THEN LASTLY, WHAT I'LL COVER IS AUSTIN IS CONSISTENTLY AMONG, UM, THE HIGHEST JOB PERFORMERS IN TERMS OF JOB GROWTH.
AND IT HAS A RELATIVELY YOUNG AND, UM, HIGHLY EDUCATED WORKFORCE.
BUT ALTHOUGH AUSTIN TYPICALLY LEADS IN MANY OF THESE SOCIOECONOMIC INDICATORS, AS I MENTIONED EARLIER, JOB GROWTH HAS SLOWED DOWN.
THERE IS A GREATER DISPERSION OF JOBS, AND WE CONTINUE TO SEE SIGNIFICANT RACIAL AND ETHNIC DISPARITIES IN MOST OF THESE SOCIOECONOMIC INDICATORS.
SO NOW I'M GONNA SHOW YOU JUST A FEW, UH, MAPS THAT KIND OF DEPICT SORT OF THE MOVEMENT OF THE POPULATION.
I TALKED ABOUT, UH, A MOVEMENT EASTWARD PRIMARILY OF FAMILIES OF COLOR.
SO LET ME GO AHEAD AND JUMP INTO THAT.
THIS, THIS MAP IS A, IS A SERIES OF THREE MAPS, AND IT'S A, IT'S A BIT DIFFICULT TO LOOK AT.
AND I, I WANT YOU TO FOCUS MORE ON THE PATTERNS IN THE ACTUAL DOTS, RIGHT? SO IT'S A DOT DENSITY MAP FOR 2020 10 AND 2020.
UM, YOU CAN SEE THE, UM, GREEN DOTS REPRESENTING THE ASIAN POPULATION.
THE PINK OR MAGENTA DOTS REPRESENT THE AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION.
ORANGE DOTS REPRESENT HISPANIC, AND THEN BLUE DOTS REPRESENT, UM, THE WHITE POPULATION.
THE LINE GOING DOWN THE MIDDLE OF THE MAP REPRESENTS I 35.
SO WHEN WE LOOK AT THE MAP IN 2000, YOU CAN SEE, YOU KNOW, THAT, UM, SEGREGATION IN COMMUNITIES WHERE MOST OF THE BLUE DOTS ARE LOCATED TO THE EAST OF I 35, WE SEE A CONCENTRATION OF PINK DOTS IN THE CENTRAL EAST AUSTIN AREA REPRESENTING THE, UH, AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION.
[01:25:01]
YOU SEE A SMALL CONCENTRATION OF GREEN DOTS IN THE CENTER OF THE MAP THAT SHOW THE ASIAN POPULATION AROUND THE UNIVERSITY AREA.AND THEN WE SEE THE, UH, ORANGE DOTS REALLY REPRESENTING THAT BACKWARDS SHAPE SEA THAT WE'VE COME TO KNOW AS THE EASTERN CRESCENT.
WHEN WE MOVED TO THE MAP IN THE CENTER FOR 2010, WHAT WE START TO SEE IS AN INCREASE OF THE, THE NUMBER OF, UM, GREEN DOTS IN THE NORTHWESTERN PARTS OF THE CITY, AND INCREASE, UH, CONCENTRATION IN THE CENTER WITH THE ASIAN POPULATION GROWING, BOTH IN NORTHWEST AS WELL AS IN, UM, THE UNIVERSITY AREA, WE SEE THOSE ORANGE DOTS MAINTAINING THAT C SHAPE, BUT MOVING, UH, FARTHER EASTWARD AS WELL.
WE ALSO SEE FEWER, UH, PINK OR MAGENTA DOTS IN THE CENTER PART OF EAST AUSTIN.
THIS IS A POINT IN TIME WHEN THE CITY OF AUSTIN EXPERIENCED A LOSS OF AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION, AND WE CAN SEE THAT IN THIS MAP.
AND THEN THE MAP IN 2020, YOU START TO SEE, UM, YOU KNOW, MORE DENSELY UH, LOCATED DOTS WITH SHOWING THE, THE GROWTH IN THE POPULATION.
YOU SEE THAT CONTINUED MOVEMENT OF THE ORANGE DOTS FARTHER EASTWARD.
UM, YOU STILL SEE FEWER PINK DOTS.
YOU SEE, UH, REALLY SIGNIFICANT CONCENTRATION OF GREEN DOTS IN THE NORTHWESTERN PARTS OF THE CITY.
THIS THE UNIVERSITY AREA, BUT NOW ALSO IN THE SOUTHWESTERN PART OF THE CITY.
AND YOU, UH, CONTINUE TO SEE A, AN EASTWARD MOVEMENT OF BLUE DOTS OR WHITE POPULATION.
NOW, UH, MOVING OVER EAST I 35 INTO HISTORIC, UH, AFRICAN AMERICAN AND HISPANIC NEIGHBORHOODS.
IN THE FOLLOWING MAPS, I WON'T GO INTO A LOT OF DETAIL, BUT THESE MAPS ARE THE SAME, UM, TYPE OF MAP FOR EACH RACE AND ETHNICITY GROUP.
AND, AND, BUT THEY'RE JUST LOOKING AT AUSTIN AND, UM, TRAVIS COUNTY AND WHAT THEY, THE MAP ON THE LEFT LOOKS AT THE SHARES OR CONCENTRATIONS OF WHERE THE, THE HIGHEST SHARES OF, OF POPULATION ARE LOCATED.
THE MAP ON THE RIGHT LOOKS AT POPULATION CHANGE, SO WHERE WE'RE SEEING GROWTH IN AREAS IN YELLOW, AND THEN WHERE WE'RE SEEING DECLINE AREAS IN BLUE OR GRAY.
SO THIS SET OF MAPS IS FOR THE AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION CHANGE IN DISTRIBUTION, AND WE CAN SEE THAT THE HIGHEST CONCENTRATIONS OF AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION ARE TO THE EAST OF MLK AND 1 180 3, BUT MOSTLY IN THE NORTHEASTERN, UH, PARTS OF TRAVIS COUNTY.
WHEN WE SEE, UM, THE CHANGE, WE SEE SIGNIFICANT GROWTH IN THIS POPULATION, AGAIN, IN THE NORTHEASTERN PARTS OF THE CITY, AND NORTHEASTERN PARTS OF TRAVIS COUNTY AS WELL AS SOUTH, FAR OFF, UH, FAR, FAR SOUTH AUSTIN.
BUT WE SEE SIGNIFICANT AREAS OF DECLINE MOSTLY IN THAT CENTRAL PART OF EAST AUSTIN, THOSE HISTORIC AFRICAN AMERICAN NEIGHBORHOODS.
UM, FOR INSTANCE, THE NEIGHBORHOOD OF CHESTNUT HAS DECLINED FROM ABOUT 24% TO ABOUT, UH, 9% WITH THE WHITE POPULATION NOW MAKING UP THE MAJORITY, UH, OF THE POPULATION IN THAT HISTORIC AFRICAN AMERICAN NEIGHBORHOOD.
UM, THIS IS THE SAME KIND OF MAP, BUT FOR THE HISPANIC POPULATION, YOU CAN REALLY SEE THE HIGHEST SHARES OF THE HISPANIC POPULATION ARE MOSTLY TO THE EAST OF, UM, THE TRAVIS COUNTY AND THE CITY OF AUSTIN.
AND ALL ALONG, UH, HIGHWAY ONE 30.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE AREAS OF GROWTH, YOU CAN REALLY SEE THAT FARTHER EASTWARD MOVEMENT TO THE FRINGES OF THE CITY OF AUSTIN AND INTO EASTERN, UH, PARTS OF TRAVIS COUNTY.
AND AGAIN, THOSE PARTS, UH, INDICATING DECLINE ARE MOSTLY FOUND IN, UH, HISTORIC, UH, HISPANIC NEIGHBORHOODS.
THE GREATEST LOSSES IN THIS POPULATION WE'RE SEEING IN THE AREAS OF RIVERSIDE AND HOLLY.
THE NEXT SET OF MAPS ARE FOR THE WHITE POPULATION.
UM, WE SEE SORT OF AN INVERSE OF THE HISPANIC POPULATION IN THIS MAP, WHERE THE, WITH THE HIGHEST SHARES, AGAIN, UM, UH, TO THE WEST OF, UM, I 35.
BUT YOU START TO SEE MORE AND MORE AREAS EAST OF I 35 THAT ARE IN THE DARKEST SHADE OF GREEN, INDICATING THAT THE, UH, WHITE POPULATION IS NOW THE MAJORITY OF THE POPULATION IN THOSE NEIGHBORHOODS.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT POPULATION CHANGE, YOU SEE A LOT OF DECLINE IN THE, UM, SORT OF SUBURBAN NEIGHBORHOODS OF NORTHWEST AUSTIN WITH A REDISTRIBUTION AND A MOVEMENT ALSO FARTHER EAST INTO THE CENTRAL CORRIDOR PARTS OF AUSTIN, AS WELL AS INTO MANY OF THOSE HISTORIC AFRICAN-AMERICAN AND HISPANIC NEIGHBORHOODS, BUT ALSO SUBURBAN GROWTH TO, UH, NORTHEASTERN PARTS OF THE CITY AND THE COUNTY, AS WELL AS SOUTHWESTERN PARTS OF THE CITY AND COUNTY.
AND THEN THE ASIAN, UM, POPULATION CHANGE AND DISTRIBUTION IS, IS REALLY MORE, UH, SUBURBAN IN NATURE.
YOU START TO SEE THE ASIAN POPULATION REALLY CONCENTRATED IN THE NORTHWESTERN PARTS
[01:30:01]
OF THE CITY AND AREAS AROUND LAKELINE AND AVERY RANCH.AND IN THE MIDDLE OF THE MAP WHERE THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS IS LOCATED.
POPULATION CHANGE HERE HAS MOVED FROM SOME OF THOSE, UH, PARTS IN NORTH, UH, CENTRAL AUSTIN TO MORE, UM, SUBURBAN AREAS IN NORTHEASTERN AUSTIN, AS WELL AS NORTHWESTERN AUSTIN, AND THEN SOUTHWESTERN PARTS OF THE CITY.
I WANNA SHARE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT I CALL AUSTIN'S UNIQUE DIVERSITY.
THIS REALLY LOOKS MORE AT THE MAKEUP OF THE POPULATION, THE FACE OF OUR POPULATION.
AND THE, AND I WANNA SHARE THIS BECAUSE IT IS A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT THAN WHAT WE'RE SEEING ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
UM, BETWEEN 2010 AND 2020 POPULATIONS OF COLOR REALLY DROVE GROWTH ALL ACROSS THE COUNTRY, AND ESPECIALLY IN THE STATE OF TEXAS BETWEEN 2010 AND 2020 AND TEXAS, 95% OF ALL GROWTH THAT WAS ADDED CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO POPULATIONS OF COLOR.
SO THIS MEANS THAT LESS THAN 5% CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO THE WHITE POPULATION.
IN AUSTIN, THE BIGGEST DRIVER OF GROWTH WAS THE WHITE POPULATION.
IT CONTRIBUTED OVER 40% OF TOTAL GROWTH DURING THAT DECADE.
AND THIS REALLY IS A UNIQUE PATTERN THAT WHEN WE LOOKED AT OTHER CITIES, WE REALLY ONLY SAW OTHER, UH, LARGE, UH, CITIES.
WE ONLY SAW OTHER FOUR, UH, FOUR OTHER CITIES THAT SHARED A SIMILAR PATTERN.
AND THOSE WERE PHOENIX, DENVER, AND RALEIGH.
THESE ARE ALL CITIES THAT HAVE, UH, A BURGEONING POPULATION.
THEY'RE, THEY'RE FAST GROWING, BUT THEY ALSO HAVE, UM, UM, AN A TECH INDUSTRY THAT'S GROWING AS WELL.
UM, THE ASIAN POPULATION IS THE FASTEST GROWING SINGLE RACE GROUP.
THIS IS, UH, REPRESENTATIVE OF WHAT'S HAPPENING ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND, AND IN THE STATE OF TEXAS.
UM, THEY CONTRIBUTED OVER 21% OF THE TOTAL GROWTH, UM, IN, UH, AUSTIN DURING THE LAST DECADE.
THE HISPANIC POPULATION ALSO GREW IN AUSTIN, UM, WITH ONE IN EVERY FIVE PEOPLE ADDED BEING OF HISPANIC DESCENT.
BUT OVER 50% OF THE GROWTH THAT WAS SEEN IN TEXAS, AND OVER 50% OF THE GROWTH THAT WAS SEEN NATIONWIDE WAS, COULD BE, UH, ATTRIBUTED TO HISPANIC POPULATION.
AND SO WHAT'S HAPPENING IN AUSTIN IS, IS REALLY UNIQUE HERE TOO.
UH, THIS IS ALSO A TIME WHERE THE HISPANIC POPULATION, EVER SINCE THE CENSUS STARTED MEASURING THE HISPANIC POPULATION WHERE WE SAW A DECLINE IN THE SHARE OF THE HISPANIC POPULATION IN AUSTIN.
UP TO THIS POINT, IT HAD BEEN GROWING THE BACK, THE BLACK POPULATION IN AUSTIN GREW IN AUSTIN THIS DECADE.
THIS WAS NOT THE CASE LAST DECADE, THIS DECADE THE BLACK POPULATION GREW.
HOWEVER, IT CONTINUES TO GROW AT A VERY SLOW PACE.
SO WE HAD ABOUT 50, UM, THOUSAND AFRICAN AMERICANS THAT WERE ADDED TO THE, UH, POPULATION OF TEXAS.
LESS THAN 1% OF THAT TOTAL GROWTH IN BLACK POPULATION TO TEXAS CAN BE FOUND IN AUSTIN.
SO WE ADDED ABOUT 5,000, UH, AFRICAN AMERICANS LAST DECADE.
SO THIS IS REALLY, UM, SIGNIFICANTLY, UM, DIFFERENT TRENDS THAT WHAT WE'RE SEEING ACROSS THE COUNTRY OVERALL.
BUT OUR POPULATION CONTINUES TO DIVERSIFY BECAUSE WE'RE SEEING GREATER DIVERSITY, UH, AND, AND GROWTH DUE TO GROWTH IN THE ASIAN POPULATION, GREATER DIVERSITY EVEN WITHIN OUR IMMIGRANT POPULATION.
HOWEVER, IT OBSCURES SOME, UM, CONCERNING PATTERNS THAT WE'RE SEEING HERE TOO.
AND SO THIS IS SORT OF THE GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATION.
I WON'T GO INTO TOO MUCH DETAIL, BUT YOU CAN SEE HOW THE SHARES HAVE CHANGED, RIGHT? SO THE, UM, UH, THE CITY CONTINUES TO DIVERSIFY.
WE HAVE A SMALLER WHITE POPULATION, GREATER POPULATIONS, UH, SHARE, UH, POPULATIONS OF COLOR.
HOWEVER, WE HAVE A SMALLER SHARE OF HISPANIC POPULATION, A CONTINUING, UH, CONTINUING SHRINKING SHARE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION TO THE POINT THAT THE ASIAN POPULATION IS NOW THE THIRD LARGEST RACE ETHNICITY GROUP IN AUSTIN.
BUT WE DO HAVE A SIGNIFICANTLY GROWING, UM, SHARE OF MULTIRACIAL OR TWO OR MORE RACE POPULATION IN OUR CITY.
AND THEN THIS IS THE, UM, SLIDE THAT I WANNA SHARE WITH YOU ON, UM, THE GROWTH PATTERNS THAT WE SAW IN THE CHILD POPULATION.
I WANNA MAKE CLEAR THAT THE CHILD POPULATION IN AUSTIN GREW.
SOMETIMES, YOU KNOW, WHEN WE COMPARE THINGS TO, YOU KNOW, FOR INSTANCE, SCHOOL ENROLLMENT, WE, WE START TO THINK THAT THERE COULD BE A DECLINE IN THE AUSTIN CHILD POPULATION.
BUT THE CHILD POPULATION IN AUSTIN GREW, HOWEVER, IT GREW MOSTLY FROM, UH, ASIAN POPULATION GROWTH FROM WHITE POPULATION GROWTH AND MULTIRACIAL POPULATION.
BUT WE SAW AN ACTUAL DECLINE IN THE NUMBER OF BLACK AND LATINO CHILDREN.
SO THERE ARE FEWER LATINO CHILDREN IN 2020 THAN WE HAD IN 2010.
AND THERE ARE FEWER AFRICAN AMERICAN CHILDREN IN 2020 THAN IN 2010.
DEMOGRAPHERS OFTEN LOOK AT THE CHILD POPULATION WHEN WE'RE
[01:35:01]
TRYING TO ANTICIPATE, UM, WHAT A, WHAT A, A CITY OR AN AREA WILL LOOK LIKE IN THE FUTURE BECAUSE CHILDREN MAKE UP, YOU KNOW, THE, THE GROWING, UH, POPULATION OF THAT AREA.AND SO IF THINGS WERE TO REMAIN THE SAME IN AUSTIN, IT COULD BE POSSIBLE THAT WE WOULD HAVE FEWER HISPANICS AND AFRICAN AMERICANS IN OUR CITY OVERALL.
NOW, WE ALSO, UM, LOOKED AT CERTAIN AREAS OF THE CITY OF AUSTIN TO SEE WHERE THE CHILD POPULATION WAS GROWING, IN PARTICULAR, WHERE HOUSEHOLDS THAT WERE FAMILIES AND HAD CHILDREN, UM, WE SAW AN, WE SAW GROWTH IN FAMILIES WITH CHILDREN IN AUSTIN, BUT WE DID SEE DECLINES THROUGHOUT MANY PARTS OF THE CITY OF AUSTIN IN TERMS OF FAMILIES WITH CHILDREN, IN PARTICULAR IN THAT EASTERN CRESCENT WHERE, UH, YOU CAN SEE ON THE MAP, UM, SHOWN IN, IN RED FOR THE MOST PART.
AND WHEN WE LOOK AT, UM, THE FAMILIES, THE BLACK FAMILIES WITH CHILDREN, WE SEE THAT.
IS THAT 20 MINUTES? THAT'S BEEN 20 MINUTES? THAT'S 20 MINUTES.
OH, WELL, UNLESS THERE'S, UM, OPPOSITION HOW MUCH LONGER? IT LOOKS LIKE YOU'VE GOT, UH, 13 MORE SLIDES.
I CAN, I CAN JUST GET, I CAN SUMMARIZE WHAT'S IN THE MAPS.
THE MAPS PRETTY MUCH SHOW THE AREAS OF DECLINE OF FAMILIES OF COLOR, AND THESE ARE GOING TO BE IN MANY PARTS OF THOSE HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS, UH, THAT ARE AFRICAN AMERICAN AND HISPANIC NEIGHBORHOODS.
BUT YOU SEE THE GROWTH IN THOSE FAMILIES WITH CHILDREN IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF THE CITY, IN THE, IN THE SUBSEQUENT SLIDES.
WHAT I SHARE WITH YOU IS THAT EVEN THOUGH AUSTIN HAS THE FOURTH MOST HIGHLY EDUCATED WORKFORCE, THERE REMAINS SIGNIFICANT EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT DISPARITIES WITH, UH, AF WITH, UM, HISPANICS CONTINUING TO HAVE MUCH LOWER EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT LEVELS THAN, UM, THAN WHITE AUSTINITES.
WE SEE THE SAME DIFFERENCES IN HOUSEHOLD INCOMES.
EVEN THOUGH HOUSEHOLD INCOMES HAVE BEEN GROWING, WE SEE SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN, UH, BLACK AND AND WHITE HOUSEHOLD INCOMES.
WHEN WE LOOK AT HOME OWNERSHIP, WE SEE IN FACT THAT HOME OWNERSHIPS HAVE STAGNATED OVERALL, AND THE BLACK WHITE HOME OWNERSHIP DIVIDE HAS ACTUALLY INCREASED IN AUSTIN INSTEAD OF DECREASED.
AND WHEN WE LOOK AT HOUSING COST BURDEN AND WHO'S REALLY BEARING THE BRUNT OF AFFORDABILITY IN AUSTIN, WE FIND THAT THERE'S A COMPOUNDING EFFECT WHERE RENTERS ARE MOST AFFECTED BY HOUSING COST BURDEN AND SPECIFICALLY RENTERS OF COLOR, IN PARTICULAR AFRICAN AMERICAN RENTERS.
JEFF, UM, PLEASE USE MY FIVE MINUTES AS WELL.
I JUST DON'T WANT YOU TO HAVE TO GO FASTER.
JUST PLEASE CONTINUE AS YOU NORMALLY WOULD IF YOU WOULD.
I'M SEEING A LOT OF NODS ON HERE, SO THANK YOU, MR. ANDERSON.
SO, UM, THE, I THINK THE, THE LAST THING THAT I, THAT I WANNA SHARE WITH YOU IS THAT THERE, YOU KNOW, THIS GOES BACK TO THIS DUALITY, RIGHT, WHERE WE FOCUS A LOT ON, UM, YOU KNOW, WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN TERMS OF GROWTH IN AUSTIN.
AND YES, OUR POPULATION CONTINUES TO GROW.
IT'S NOT GROWING AS FAST, BUT IT'S STILL GROWING.
WE'RE ADDING A LOT OF HOUSING UNITS, UH, BUT WE'RE NOT KEEPING PACE WITH HOUSEHOLD FORMATION.
AND THAT COULD HAVE SERIOUS IMPLICATIONS ON AFFORDABILITY AS WELL AS HOME OWNERSHIP.
WE'RE ALREADY LAGGING IN TERMS OF HOME OWNERSHIP, UH, WITH THE STAGNATION THAT WE'RE SEEING FOR MOST GROUPS, MOST RACE ETHNICITY GROUPS.
AND SO I THINK WHAT I WOULD SHARE WITH YOU IS JUST WHEN YOU'RE CONSIDERING, UM, DECISIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO CITY COUNCIL AND TO CITY LITER LEADERSHIP, IS THAT YOU KEEP SOME OF THESE DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFTS IN MIND AND DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS IN MIND.
BECAUSE WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS AUSTIN IN AUSTIN IS TRULY UNIQUE IN TERMS OF THOSE DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFTS, AND THEY REALLY, UM, SPEAK TO SOME OF OUR HISTORIC DEMOGRAPHIC, UM, TRENDS THAT HAVE BEEN IN PLACE FOR SOME TIME.
THERE WERE LOTS OF POLICIES LEADING UP TO THIS POINT THAT HAVE IMPLICATED MANY OF THESE FINDINGS.
AND SO I WOULD SUGGEST THAT YOU KEEP THESE DEMOGRAPHIC, UH, IN MIND AS YOU ARE MAKING FU FUTURE DECISIONS, BECAUSE POLICIES THAT ARE PUT IN PLACE TODAY COULD HAVE LONGSTANDING EFFECTS THAT AFFECT OUR COMMUNITIES DIFFERENTLY.
UM, COMMISSIONER JOHNSON, THANK YOU.
UH, AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR PRESENTATION.
JUST TAKING OFF OF THAT VERY LAST POINT YOU MADE, I'M LOOKING AT, UH, I THINK IT'S SLIDE 30, UH, IT'S A TABLE SHOWING THE PROJECTED POPULATIONS FOR THE COUNTIES THAT MAKE UP THE AUSTIN METRO AREA.
UM, I THINK IT'S PAGE 30 OR PAGE.
UM, OBVIOUSLY THESE ARE GUESSES.
I MEAN, THEY'RE EDUCATED GUESSES, THEY'RE PROJECTIONS.
TO WHAT EXTENT DO POLICY DECISIONS LIKE LAND USE AND HOUSING PRODUCTION
[01:40:01]
AND, AND THINGS THAT CITIES OR OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN CONTROL? HOW DO THESE FACTOR INTO THESE PROJECTIONS? AND, YOU KNOW, WHEN I LOOK AT THE PROJECTION THAT HAYES COUNTY WILL QUADRUPLE IN POPULATION, BUT TRAVIS COUNTY WILL LESS THAN DOUBLE.I MEAN, WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS BASICALLY WE PROJECT SPRAWL STYLE DEVELOPMENT WILL CONTINUE MUCH FASTER THAN URBAN LIVING.
PEOPLE WILL MOVE TO SUBURBS MORE AND MORE OVER TIME.
ARE THERE POLICY DECISIONS OR POLICY TOOLS THAT THE CITY HAS THAT COULD COUNTERACT SOME OF THESE PROJECTIONS AND COULD INSTEAD COMPETE WITH HAYES COUNTY OR WILLIAMSON COUNTY OR CALDWELL COUNTY FOR THOSE RESIDENTS AND GET THEM TO INSTEAD CHOOSE TO LIVE IN TRAVIS COUNTY OR IN THE CITY OF AUSTIN? SURE.
SO, SO I HEARD A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS AND, AND I'LL ADDRESS THE FIRST ONE REALLY QUICKLY.
SO TYPICALLY, UM, PROJECTIONS THAT ARE, THAT ARE PRODUCED USING A DEMOGRAPHIC METHOD ARE NOT TYPICALLY INFORMED BY LAND USE POLICIES OR, YOU KNOW, ANY SORT OF, UM, POLICIES ON, ON THOSE SORTS OF ISSUES.
BUT, UM, WE AT THE CITY OF AUSTIN HAVE PRODUCED IN THE PAST, THESE COME FROM THE TEXAS DEMOGRAPHIC CENTER, BUT WE HAVE PRODUCED IN THE PAST, UM, POPULATION FORECAST, UH, SMALL AREA FORECASTS THAT TAKE, UM, DEPARTMENT, YOU KNOW, CITY DEPARTMENT EXPERTS, UH, TAKE THOSE CITYWIDE PROJECTIONS AND THEN REALLY DISAGGREGATE IT THROUGHOUT THE CITY TO SAY, THESE ARE THE AREAS IN PARTICULAR THAT WE THINK WILL GROW FOR, YOU KNOW, THESE NUMBER OF REASONS.
AND THEY'RE CONTROLLED TO THAT LARGER PROJECTION THAT IS LARGELY DEMOGRAPHIC IN NATURE.
SO WE'RE GOING TO BE UPDATING THAT PROCESS, UH, AT THE END OF THIS YEAR.
IT SHOULD HAVE OUR FINAL, UH, SMALL AREA FORECAST EARLY NEXT YEAR.
AND SO THEY WILL BE AVAILABLE TO, UH, TO BE USED TO INFORM, UH, A POLICY AND DECISION MAKING.
WHAT TOOLS ARE THERE AVAILABLE? I THINK IF, I THINK WHAT THE DATA SUGGESTS, YOU KNOW, WHEN WE LOOKED AT THE CHANGE WITHIN AUSTIN, THE GROWTH, UM, WITHIN AUSTIN, WE REALLY DID SEE A COMBINATION.
WE SAW GROWTH IN THOSE, UM, FARTHER AREAS ALONG THE FRINGES OF THE CITY WHERE THERE COULD BE MORE DEVELOPMENT.
BUT WE ALSO SAW WHERE THE CITY WAS MORE INTENTIONAL ABOUT INCREASING DENSITY WITHIN THE CITY CORE.
WE SAW POPULATION GROWTH THERE.
AND SO I THINK THAT THAT WOULD TELL ME THAT IN THE FUTURE, IF WE CONTINUE TO ENCOURAGE THOSE SORTS OF POLICIES IN, YOU KNOW, THE CITY CORE, THAT WE COULD ADD MORE HOUSING THAT COULD COMPETE WITH PLACES LIKE HAYES COUNTY AND WILLIAMSON COUNTY.
NOW THE OTHER THING I WILL SAY THOUGH IS THAT TRAVIS COUNTY, THIS TIME FOR THE, FOR THE FIRST TIME IN 20 YEARS, EXPERIENCED MORE OUT MIGRATION THAN IN MIGRATION.
SLOWER JOB GROWTH, SLOWER POPULATION GROWTH IN AUSTIN, UH, ESPECIALLY FROM OTHER PLACES ACROSS THE COUNTRY, COULD REALLY CHANGE THAT, RIGHT? AND SO WE REALLY NEED TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHY ARE NOT AS MANY PEOPLE COMING INTO AUSTIN AS THEY USED TO, WHY ARE THEY NOT COMING HERE AS RAPIDLY? AND IF IT IS ISSUES OF AFFORDABILITY, NOT THAT ARE NOT ONLY ATTRACTING PEOPLE HERE, BUT ALSO PUSHING PEOPLE OUT MM-HMM,
AND I THINK IT IS COMPELLING TO LOOK AT THESE MAPS, ESPECIALLY WHERE YOU, UH, DEMONSTRATED THIS SORT OF RELATIVE CHANGE IN POPULATIONS BY RACIAL GROUPS.
AND THAT, AS YOU POINTED OUT, AREAS THAT SAW ALL FOUR SORT OF SUBGROUPS OF POPULATION GROWING DURING THIS TIME WERE THE FRINGES OF THE CITY AND DOWNTOWN AND THE DOMAIN AREAS THAT ARE CHEAP BECAUSE THEY'RE FAR AWAY OR RELATIVELY AFFORDABLE BECAUSE THEY ARE VERY DENSE.
AND SO THAT IS ENCOURAGING THAT IT ISN'T THE ONLY SOLUTION BEING THAT PEOPLE HAVE TO LEAVE IF THEY WANT TO FIND A DIFFERENT LIFESTYLE, IF THEY WANNA FIND SOMETHING THEY CAN AFFORD.
WE DO SEEM TO HAVE TOOLS THAT SEEM TO BE WORKING TO SOME EXTENT TO BOTH PROMOTE RELATIVE AFFORDABILITY AND ALSO HELP TO PROMOTE DIVERSITY AND RETAIN SOME OF THE POPULATIONS THAT ARE SHRINKING RELATIVE TO THE CITY AS A WHOLE.
I, I DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.
LET'S TAKE DOWN, OKAY, LET'S SEE.
COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS, SO I KIND OF HAVE A DIFFERENT TAKE THAN YOU DO COMMISSIONER, BECAUSE IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE ANY OF THOSE TOOLS ARE BEING EFFECTIVE AND HAVE, AND HELPING AFRICAN AMERICANS AND HISPANICS REMAIN IN THE CITY.
SO I I WOULD ASK YOU, BECAUSE THEY SEEM TO BE BEING PUSHED OR DISPERSED TO THE EASTERN CRESCENT, UM, YOU CAN SEE THE MIGRATION
[01:45:01]
OF, OF THOSE POPULATIONS FROM THEIR TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOODS FARTHER AND FARTHER EAST AND BEYOND THE CITY LIMITS AS WE LOOK AT THESE MAPS.SO WHATEVER TOOLS THAT WE HAVE ARE NOT REALLY HELPING TO, TO SECURE THOSE POPULATIONS.
CAN YOU SPEAK TO, TO WHY? NO, NOT NECESSARILY.
I CAN'T SPEAK DIRECTLY TO, TO WHY, RIGHT.
BUT I, I, I DID SEE THE SAME PATTERNS IN THE DATA THAT YOU'RE, THAT YOU'RE SPEAKING TO.
UM, WHEN WE SAW EVEN THOSE FAST GROWING AREAS THAT ADDED A THOUSAND UNITS OR MORE, IF THEY WERE CLOSER TO THE CITY CORE, THEY WERE LESS LIKELY TO YIELD INCREASING POPULATION WITH INCREASING DIVERSITY.
THEY WERE, THEY WERE MORE LIKELY TO BE DRIVEN BY, BY WHITE POPULATION GROWTH.
BUT THERE WAS SOMETHING ABOUT WHAT WAS DONE IN DIFFERENT AREAS OF THE CITY IN FARTHER FRINGES THAT DID PRODUCE THAT DIVERSITY.
AND SO IT COULD BE, UM, WORTH EXPLORING, UM, AT THE CITY, UM, IN OUR DEPARTMENT, IN THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT WAS PUT IN PLACE IN SOME OF THESE AREAS THAT DID HELP TO PRODU TO PRODUCE THAT DIVERSIFICATION.
ONE AREA WHERE, I DON'T KNOW THAT THE CITY WAS DOING A WHOLE LOT WAS THE AREA OF TECH RIDGE.
AND TECH RIDGE IS THE MOST, UM, DIVERSE AREA IN THE CITY OF AUSTIN.
IT HAS LITERALLY ABOUT 25% ASIAN POPULATION, 25% HISPANIC, 25% BLACK, 25% WHITE POPULATION.
SO WHAT INTERVENTIONS, YOU KNOW, WERE TAKING PLACE THERE? I I'M NOT, I'M NOT FAMILIAR WITH ANY THAT WERE HAPPENING THERE, BUT THERE WAS SOMETHING ABOUT THAT KIND OF DEVELOPMENT THAT DID HELP TO PRODUCE THAT DIVERSITY.
SO I THINK LOOKING AT THOSE AREAS WHERE WE DID SEE, UM, INCREASED DIVERSITY WITH, UH, PAIRED WITH GREATER UNITS, UH, PRODUCED, COULD BE HELPFUL TO UNDERSTAND WHAT COULD BE REPRODUCED.
AND WE DO KNOW THAT THE FARTHER YOU GET THE FARTHER EAST AND TECH RIDGE AREA, UH, FOR EXAMPLE, THAT THE RENTS ARE CHEAPER, THE HOMES ARE CHEAPER.
UM, AND SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT MEDIAN INCOME, UH, AND MATCHING UP MEDIAN INCOME OF AFRICAN AMERICANS AND HISPANICS, THEY OBVIOUSLY ARE MOVING TO THE PLACES THAT THEY CAN AFFORD TO MOVE EITHER AT THE FAR FLUNG AREAS OF THE CITY, EAST AND CRESCENT OR BEYOND THE CITY LIMITS.
OBVIOUSLY THE HOME AND RENT PRICES HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH THAT.
YES, WE DID SEE AREAS WHERE THERE, YOU KNOW, WHERE THERE IS INCREASED AFFORDABILITY.
UM, I THINK IN THE, IN THE TECH RICH AREA, IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE THERE IS, THERE WAS DIFFERENT TYPES OF GROWTH.
THERE WAS A LOT OF MULTI-FAMILY, UM, UNIT GROWTH, BUT THERE WAS ALSO A LOT OF, UM, SINGLE FAMILY UNIT GROWTH.
AND I THINK WHAT WAS INTERESTING ABOUT THAT AREA THAT'S WORTH EXPLORING IS THAT WE SAW DIVERSIFICATION AMONG ALL GROUPS.
AND SO IT, SO IT WASN'T JUST THE AFFORDABILITY THAT WAS APPEALING TO THAT AREA, I DON'T THINK.
AND SO, UM, BUT I AGREE WITH YOU, YES, AS YOU GO FARTHER OUT, YOU KNOW, THERE'S UM, MORE LAND, MORE AFFORDABLE LAND TO DEVELOP, AND SO IT'S LIKELY GOING TO PRODUCE, UM, UH, LOWER RENTS AND A LOWER, UH, HOME PRICES AS WELL.
AND WITHIN THIS, UM, THE INFORMATION THAT YOU'RE GATHERING, ARE YOU LOOKING AT, UH, ANY KIND OF STUDY AND TRACKING OF DISPLACEMENT? BECAUSE IT'S KIND OF CONCERNING THAT WE'RE LOSING BLACK FAMILIES AND, UM, MEXICAN AMERICAN AND HISPANIC FAMILIES IN PARTICULAR WITHIN THIS WHOLE, UM, CATEGORY OF PEOPLE OF COLOR.
UM, FOLKS THAT GENERATIONALLY HAVE LIVED HERE AND BUILT THE CITY OF AUSTIN HELPED TO BUILD THIS, THE CITY OF AUSTIN.
ARE YOU LOOKING AT ANY, UH, OF THOSE FACTORS OR TRYING TO STUDY THAT TO FIGURE OUT WHAT'S HAPPENING AND HOW WE ADDRESS THAT VERY TROUBLING TREND? SO WE'VE WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH OUR, UH, COLLEAGUES AT THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT WHO ARE REALLY FOCUSED ON UNDERSTANDING, UH, AND, AND PREVENTING DISPLACEMENT, RIGHT, MITIGATING DISPLACEMENT.
UM, AND WE ARE FAMILIAR WITH THE, WITH THE, WITH THE STUDIES THAT HAVE BEEN DONE HERE IN AUSTIN AND CONTINUE TO UPDATE AND HELP TO UPDATE THAT INFORMATION TO UNDERSTAND WHERE THOSE DYNAMICS ARE TAKING PLACE, WHAT NEW AREAS ARE AT RISK.
UM, BUT BEYOND THAT, IT'S, IT'S QUITE DIFFICULT TO STUDY DISPLACEMENT.
WE GET A LOT OF INFORMATION ON PEOPLE WHO MOVE INTO THE AREA, BUT WE DON'T QUITE KNOW WHERE THEY GO.
AND THE, THE CENSUS BUREAU HAS ACTUALLY BEEN PRODUCING LESS DATA ON THAT.
WE USED TO BE ABLE TO GET COUNTY LEVEL DATA THAT TOLD US THE NUMBER OF MOVERS INTO THE AREA AND AS WELL AS THE NUMBER OF MOVERS OUT, BUT WE DON'T HAVE THAT ANYMORE.
COMMISSIONER PHILLIPS, IF YOU HAD MORE QUESTIONS, YOU CAN TAKE MY TIME.
I KNOW THIS WAS AN ITEM THAT YOU HAD REALLY BEEN WANTING.
WELL, I JUST HAVE, UM, A COMMENT, UM, 'CAUSE I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT ABOUT THE CENSUS DATA
[01:50:01]
BECAUSE, UM, WE CAN JUST LOOK AT THE CITY OF PFLUGERVILLE AND WHAT HAS HAPPENED, HOW IT WENT FROM BEING, YOU KNOW, A, YOU KNOW, VERY WHITE CITY NOW TO BEING A MAJORITY, UH, OR, OR AT LEAST A PLURALITY BLACK CITY.UM, AND THAT WAS ALL DRIVEN THAT THOSE, UH, FOLKS WERE FOLKS WHO MOVED FROM AUSTIN TO PFLUGERVILLE.
SO, BUT I WOULD BE INTERESTED IN JUST GETTING MORE INFORMATION ABOUT HOW THESE THINGS LINE UP, UM, WITH REGARDS TO IT.
IT, IT'S AN INTERESTING, I THINK THAT YOU POINTED OUT EVEN THE LAKELINE AREA, BUT THESE OUTER LYING AREAS THAT ARE DR DRAWING, UM, UH, POPULATIONS OF BLACKS AND HISPANICS, I'D BE MORE, UM, INTERESTED IN LOOKING AT SOME OF THE AFFORDABILITY, WHAT, YOU KNOW, HOW THAT LINES UP WITH ARE, ARE FAMILIES ALSO MOVING INTO THOSE AREAS AND ARE THEY MOVING OUT OF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AS WELL? DO, DO YOU HAVE AN, DO YOU KNOW WHETHER OR NOT, UM, THE POPULATIONS OF, OF LATINO AND AFRICAN AMERICANS IN AIS A ISD WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS? I KNOW THAT IT'S SHRINKING FOR BLACKS, BUT IS THAT, IS, IS IT ALSO SHRINKING FOR HISPANICS? YES, WE HAD, WE HAVE DEFINITELY SEEN, I DON'T KNOW OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD THE LATEST NUMBERS, BUT WE HAVE DEFINITELY SEEN THAT PATTERN WHERE WE ARE SEEING MORE HISPANICS AND AFRICAN AMERICANS MOVING OUT OF THE, UM, THE AUSTIN SCHOOL DISTRICT.
UM, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I'LL MENTION ABOUT PFLUGERVILLE IS THAT WE ALSO SAW A DECLINE IN THE CHILD POPULATION OF AFRICAN AMERICANS AND HISPANICS IN, IN PFLUGERVILLE.
AND SO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT IS ALSO HAPPENING IN, IN OTHER SURROUNDING CITIES WHERE, FOR INSTANCE, HURO AND MAYER ARE SEEING INCREDIBLE GROWTH IN AFRICAN AMERICAN FAMILIES.
SO I THINK THERE, THERE COULD BE A CONNECTION BETWEEN THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND, YOU KNOW, THERE HAVE BEEN CONVERSATIONS ABOUT ALSO CLOSING SCHOOLS IN PFLUGERVILLE ISD, SO HOW, YOU KNOW, HOW THE SCHOOL, UM, RELATES TO POPULATION GROWTH IN THE AREA AND THE MAKEUP OF FAMILIES THERE TOO COULD BE AN INTERESTING THING TO EXPLORE.
OTHER QUESTIONS YOU SEE COMMISSIONER MAXWELL AND THEN COMMISSIONER HANEY.
UH, THIS IS A GREAT SEGUE INTO MY QUESTIONS.
UM, I WAS LUCKY ENOUGH TO HEAR A PRESENTATION A FEW YEARS AGO ABOUT AUSTIN'S UPDATED DEMOGRAPHICS RELATED TO THE CENSUS, AND I WAS JUST CURIOUS IF YOU COULD SPEAK TO THAT, BECAUSE I KNOW WE'VE HAD SOME ISSUES WITH UNDERCOUNTING AND JUST GENERALLY HOW WE'RE FEELING ABOUT THE QUALITY OF THE DATA, ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF, IT SOUNDS LIKE THE FACT THAT WE'RE NOT GETTING AS MUCH GRANULAR DATA AT THE COUNTY LEVEL, UM, WITH SOME OF THE CHANGES AT THE CENSUS AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL WITH THE CENSUS BUREAU.
YES, THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION.
I THINK THAT, UM, THAT INQUIRY IS STILL, IS STILL OUT THERE.
UM, BUT WE HAVE INTERNAL, UM, DATA THAT REALLY SUGGESTS THAT THE CENSUS BUREAU SEVERELY UNDERCOUNTED THE CITY OF AUSTIN IN GENERAL, WE THINK THAT COULD HAVE RANGED ANYWHERE FROM 9,000 TO 20,000 IN POPULATION.
AND THE, UH, POPULATION ESTIMATES THAT WE HAVE ON OUR WEBSITE ACTUALLY, UM, THEY, THEY INCLUDE THAT UNDER COUNT OR, OR THEY, UH, COMPENSATE FOR THAT UNDER COUNT, UM, USING OUR INTERNAL DATA.
SO WE BELIEVE THAT THOSE NUMBERS ARE MUCH MORE ACCURATE.
ANYONE WHO'S LOOKING TO COMPARE THE CENSUS BUREAU'S ESTIMATE FOR THE CITY OF AUSTIN WITH THE ESTIMATE THAT'S ON OUR WEBPAGE WILL NOTICE THAT THERE, THERE IS A DIFFERENCE OF ABOUT 9,000 TO 20,000 IN POPULATION.
AND IT'S BECAUSE WE REALLY ARE RELYING ON INTERNAL DATA.
UNFORTUNATELY, WHAT I THINK IS HAPPENING WITH THE AFRICAN AMERICAN AND HISPANIC, UM, CHILD POPULATION IS NOT ONLY RELATED TO UNDER COUNT, CHILDREN OF COLOR ARE ABSOLUTELY ONE OF THE MOST UNDER COUNTED GROUPS, BUT WE LOOKED AT THE PERCENTAGE THAT COULD BE ATTRIBUTED TO, UM, UNDER COUNT IN THE CHILD POPULATION THAT WAS SPECIFIC TO TRAVIS COUNTY FROM THE CENSUS BUREAU.
AND EVEN THEN IT WAS A VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE.
AND SO I ACTUALLY COMPENSATED FOR THAT UNDER COUNT IN OUR POPULATION ESTIMATES, BUT IT STILL DID NOT BRING US INTO A NET POSITIVE FOR THE TOTAL COUNT OF BLACK AND HISPANIC CHILDREN.
UH, AND, AND THE NET COUNT BETWEEN 2010 AND 2020.
SO I THINK IT'S STILL IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THAT WHILE THE CENSUS BUREAU MAY NOT BE GETTING ALL OF OUR DATA CORRECT, THEY'RE STILL REFLECTING SOME REALITIES THAT WE NEED TO TACKLE
AND, AND I GUESS MORE GENERALLY, UH, I KNOW IT'S ONLY 2024, BUT DO YOU HAVE SOME ASPIRATIONS FOR HOW WE MIGHT BETTER GET A MORE ACCURATE COUNT FOR THE NEXT
[01:55:01]
AUSTIN, IN TRAVIS COUNTY? YEAH, TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, AND, AND I REALLY APPRECIATE THAT QUESTION BECAUSE YES, WE, WE HAVE LOTS OF IDEAS ON OUR TEAM AND WE'RE WORKING REALLY HARD ALREADY.I KNOW THAT THE CENSUS SOUNDS, YOU KNOW, 2030 SOUNDS SO FAR AWAY, BUT FOR US RIGHT NOW, WE'RE REALLY LAYING THE FOUNDATION TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND HOW WE CAN GET THAT MOST ACCURATE COUNT BECAUSE THAT COUNT RELATES TO MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF DOLLARS THAT COME BACK TO COMMUNITIES FOR PROGRAMS LIKE DISPLACEMENT PREVENTION AND, AND LOTS OF OTHER PROGRAMS, RIGHT? BUT SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE THINK IS GONNA BE CRITICALLY IMPORTANT, EVEN THOUGH MIGRATION DATA IS HARD TO FIND, OUR BIGGEST ISSUE IS REALLY MAKING SURE THAT EVERY SINGLE HOUSING UNIT THAT IS PRESENT IN AUSTIN IS ON THE CENSUS BUREAU'S MASTER ADDRESS FILE LIST, BECAUSE ONLY THOSE ADDRESSES THAT ARE ON THAT LIST RECEIVE AN INVITATION TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CENSUS.
AND SO GETTING THE MOST ACCURATE HOUSING UNIT COUNT THAT WE CAN FOR THE CITY OF AUSTIN IS OF CRITICAL IMPORTANCE.
AND WE HAVE MULTIPLE INTERNAL DATA SOURCES THAT WE CAN USE, BUT I WILL BE HONEST WITH YOU, THEY ALL HAVE SOME QUIRKS AND QUALITY ASSURANCE ISSUES THAT WE REALLY NEED TO STRAIGHTEN OUT IN ORDER TO GET THAT ACCURATE COUNT.
AND SO I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH OUR COLLEAGUES IN, IN THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT AT AUSTIN ENERGY THAT HAS SUCH, UM, HIGH QUALITY, UM, UTILITY CONNECTION DATA AND, AND LOTS OF OTHER PARTNERS AROUND THE CITY TO REALLY HELP US FULLY UNDERSTAND WHAT IS THE FULL INVENTORY OF HOUSING UNITS, UH, IN AUSTIN.
BECAUSE RIGHT NOW WE CAN GIVE YOU A RELATIVELY GOOD ESTIMATE, BUT WE DON'T KNOW THAT FOR CERTAIN.
AND I JUST HAVE ONE QUICK QUESTION IF I DO HAVE A SECOND LEFT, WHICH IS TO ASK YOU ABOUT THE IMPACT OF THE ETJ AND THE SUB.
SOME WE'VE SEEN SOME, UH, FOLKS REMOVE THEMSELVES FROM CITY OF AUSTIN, AND DO YOU THINK THAT THIS IS GONNA BE AN ONGOING TREND THAT WE'LL HAVE TO REALLY THINK ABOUT, ESPECIALLY IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF OUR CITY IN TERMS OF WHAT THAT IMPACTS OUR DEMOGRAPHICS? SO CURRENTLY THE CENSUS BUREAU DETERMINES THE CITY OF AUSTIN'S POPULATION BASED ON ITS LIMITED PURPOSE AND FULL PURPOSE POPULATION.
AND SO REALLY ONLY THOSE, UH, FOLKS WHO, UM, THROUGH, UH, AN ELECTION, UM, OPT TO DE ANNEX, WOULD THAT POPULATION BE IMPACTED.
ETJ WOULD NOT VERY MUCH BE IMPACTED.
OF COURSE, IT WOULD BE INTO THE FUTURE IF THOSE WERE FUTURE ANNEXATION POSSIBILITIES.
SO THE DE ANNEXATION SO FAR HAVE NOT REALLY SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTED THESE NUMBERS, AND YOU WOULDN'T EXPECT THAT TO BE A PROBLEM IMMEDIATELY? NOT IMMEDIATELY.
WE DO HAVE AN ESTIMATE OF WHAT THAT WAS.
I I CAN'T REMEMBER THAT OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD, BUT I THINK IT WAS IN THE THREE THOUSANDS.
UM, SO WE DON'T, BUT, SO IT'S, IT'S A, IT'S A MARGINAL IMPACT AT THIS POINT IN TIME.
YEAH, UH, JUST A COUPLE OF QUICK QUESTIONS.
UM, SO I, I KNOW WE HAVE OUR PROJECTIONS, UM, ON, YOU KNOW, WHO'S GOING OR WE, HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE GOING WHERE DO WE KNOW WHO THOSE PEOPLE ARE GONNA BE? I MEAN, DO, DO WE HAVE ANY PROJECTIONS LIKE, YOU KNOW, HOW MANY OF THOSE PEOPLE ARE GONNA BE BLACK, HISPANIC, ASIAN, CAUCASIAN? SO, UM, WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT WHO'S GOING WHERE, I CAN TELL YOU, UH, OUR, OUR PROJECTIONS, UM, OUR NEXT SERIES OF PROJECTIONS WILL BE DEMOGRAPHIC METHOD PROJECTIONS.
AND SO WE HOPE TO HAVE PROJECTIONS THAT, UM, ARE ABLE TO TELL US THE SHARE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION THAT WE'RE PROJECTED TO HAVE IN THE FUTURE, UM, THE SHARE OF HISPANIC CHILDREN.
AND SO WE'LL HAVE THAT DEMOGRAPHIC DETAIL FOR THE CITY AS A WHOLE.
SO, BUT IN TERMS OF WHO'S GOING WHERE AND WHAT THEIR MAKEUP IS, I CAN TELL YOU THAT THE PEOPLE WHO MOVE TO AUSTIN, UM, HAVE SPECIFIC CHARACTERISTICS THAT, UM, YOU KNOW, THAT SORT OF, UM, HAVE IMPLICATIONS ON THE PATTERNS THAT WE'RE SEEING NOW.
SO THEY TEND TO BE YOUNGER, UM, THAN, THAN THE PEOPLE WHO ARE ALREADY HERE.
SO THEY'RE TYPICALLY IN THEIR EARLY THIRTIES, UH, THEY TEND TO HAVE EVEN HIGHER EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT THAN THE AUSTINITES WHO ARE ALREADY HERE.
I MENTIONED WE HAD THE FOURTH MOST HIGHLY EDUCATED WORKFORCE.
THEY COME WITH EVEN HIGHER SHARES OF EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT.
UM, THEY ALSO COME WITH HIGHER, UH, PERSONAL INCOMES, UM, UM, NUMBERS.
AND SO THEY HAVE MORE AFFLUENCE WHEN THEY'RE MOVING HERE.
SO THEY'RE MUCH MORE, UM, BETTER EQUIPPED TO, UH, COMPETE IN A, IN A TIGHT HOUSING MARKET.
AND THEY ALSO ARE LESS DIVERSE.
THEY TEND TO BE HIGHER SHARES OF WHITE POPULATION MOVING INTO THE AREA, UH, RELATIVE TO THE POPULATION MAKEUP AS A WHOLE AND PEOPLE WHO DO NOT MOVE OR PEOPLE WHO MOVE FROM AROUND THE, THE METRO AREA IN THE FUTURE.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT COULD LOOK LIKE.
[02:00:01]
WOULD ESTIMATE THAT WE WOULD CONTINUE, WE WOULD ASSUME THAT WE WOULD CONTINUE TO SEE THOSE TRENDS.AND SO THAT WOULD KIND OF BE BAKED INTO THOSE.
UM, BUT THAT'S WHAT WE'VE BEEN SEEING FOR, FOR A FEW YEARS NOW IS, IS THOSE MAIN, UH, CHARACTERISTICS OF PEOPLE MOVING INTO, INTO AUSTIN FROM, ESPECIALLY FROM OTHER STATES.
AND THE SECOND, I, I WAS SURPRISED I DIDN'T REALIZE THAT WE HAD NET OUT MIGRATION FROM TRAVIS COUNTY.
UM, IS THAT GENERALLY TO OTHER PLACES WITHIN THE REGION, UH, LIKE HAYES CALDWELL SORT OF THING, OR IS THAT FURTHER AFIELD? SO I WAS HOPING TO BE ABLE TO ANSWER THAT LATER ON THIS YEAR, WAITING FOR SOME CENSUS DATA.
AND THEN THEY'VE JUST RECENTLY TOLD US THAT THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE, UM, SHARING THAT, UM, OUT MIGRATION DATA ANY LONGER.
THE CENSUS BUREAU IS WORKING TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY OF ITS RESPONDENTS TO ITS SURVEYS.
SO WE HAVE LESS ACCESS TO THE GRANULAR DATA THAT WE USED TO HAVE IN THE PAST.
HISTORICALLY, WHAT WE HAD SEEN WAS THAT OUT MIGRATION FROM TRAVIS COUNTY TYPICALLY STAYED WITHIN THE REGION, SO IT WOULD GO TO HAYES COUNTY, WILLIAMSON COUNTY, THOSE TWO IN PARTICULAR WOULD GET THE BULK OF, OF OUT MIGRANTS.
WE HAVEN'T SEEN A NEGATIVE OUT MIGRATION SINCE THE.COM BUST.
AND SO WE ANTICIPATE THAT THE DISPLACEMENT COULD BE HAPPENING TO NEIGHBORING, UM, LOCAL, UM, YOU KNOW, COUNTY SURROUNDING IN WITHIN THE REGION, BUT WE HAVE FEWER DOMESTIC MIGRANTS AND WE'VE HAD THAT DISPLACEMENT GOING ON, BUT IT'S REALLY BEEN SORT OF OBSCURED AGAIN FROM THOSE HIGHER DOMESTIC MIGRATION NUMBER.
SO WE WERE ALWAYS IN THE POSITIVE EVEN THOUGH WE WERE HAVING DISPLACEMENT.
AND SO NOW IT'S EASIER TO SEE THAT.
UNFORTUNATELY, WE DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHERE WE'RE GOING, BUT WE ARE EXPLORING DIFFERENT DATA SOURCES TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND HOW WE CAN FIGURE THAT OUT, INCLUDING US POSTAL SERVICE ADDRESS CHANGE DATA AND OTHER DATA SOURCES THAT, THAT WE MAY BE ABLE TO PURCHASE OR JUST, YOU KNOW, UH, UH, ACQUIRE TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHERE IT IS THAT THEY'RE GOING SINCE WE NO LONGER HAVE THAT FROM THE CENSUS BUREAU.
ALL RIGHT, TWO MORE SPOTS FOR QUESTIONS.
IF THERE'S NO MORE QUESTIONS THEN MS. VALENCIA, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS REALLY HELPFUL PRESENTATION AND UM, I THINK IT'S GOING TO HELP US UNDERSTAND SOME OF OUR RECOMMENDATIONS MOVING FORWARD.
UM, SO REALLY APPRECIATE YOU COMING TO OUR SPECIAL CALLED MEETING THIS EVENING AND WE'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW.
UM, DIFFERENT TIME, DIFFERENT CHANNEL.
WE'RE GONNA BE BACK IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS AT 6:00 PM BUT I WILL ADJOURN THIS MEETING TONIGHT AT 7:06 PM THANK YOU.
I FALLEN ALL OVER MYSELF TO LIFT YOUR HEART WITH.